Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

Chinese Chess Fan-Thread

Public forum discussion.

General

#51 · Tim Shih

21 May 2012

@Ricardo, Thank you so much for sharing this message with us. May I ask you two questions: (1) Are there ratings of Xiangqi around? (2) Have you studied openings? (or perhaps I should ask: approximately how many hours have you devoted to studying the tactics of openings?)

#52 · Ricardo (Santos)

22 May 2012

Tim, I'm not so sure about the ratings, but I found some interesting ratings on this site the European-German Xiangqi Federation, however it doesn't seem to be updated too frequently. It was updated last time January 2011! According to this the world rating is:
1 Zhao Xinxin 10-14 (2630) China
2 Xu Yinchuan 13-54 (2609) China
3 Wan Chunlin 14-15 (2602) China
4 Lü Qin 15-56 (2595) China
5 Hong Zhi 15-24 (2595) China

Another interesting website is the Toronto Xiangqi Association

No, I'm sorry, I would not say that I have studied Xiangqi openings really... I'm an amateur :) But I'd love to learn more! Do you have a favorit opening? What are your thoughts about for example a central cannon opening?

#53 · mungo

23 May 2012

And an explanation to the rating can be found here

Rating goes from 10 for world champ to 250 for beginner. After the dash means on how many tournaments the rating is based, so for number 1 Zhao Xinxin, 10-14 means rating as world champ (10) based on 14 tournaments.

#54 · Tim Shih

23 May 2012

@mungo, Thank you. Both your information and Ricardo's information are very helpful and valuable.

@Ricardo, If I am the first-move player, yes, I tend to play the central cannon opening. If I am the 2nd-move player and if my opponent plays the central cannon (left side) move, I tend to play the knight of the right side to protect my central pawn. But I have not studied a single opening book. So, my openings are entirely amateurish. :) It is gratifying to know that Xiangqi has become worldwide.

#55 · Ricardo (Santos)

24 May 2012

This is interesting, I usually play the right hand side cannon, not the left hand side cannon... thus
1. C2=5 H2+3
but I think you mean
1. C8=5 H2+3

I guess there is no real difference in the first move of the red (from left or right doesn't matter), but with the first move of the black there is a difference, since you either have a diagonal power distrubtion or a vertical power distribution. So if you want to keep the diagonal, which I would choose as the first move for black if red is playing the central cannon, in your case I would play after 1. C8=5 H8+7

Do you see any difference in this when it comes to advantage for red or black? I couldn't tell which is better, I just have a better "dynamic" and "balanced" feeling if I as black get the diagonal power distribution...

#57 · Ricardo (Santos)

15 Dec 2012

... and here comes a wish for the year 2013... Chinese Chess on Little Golem ;))

#58 · gamesorry

16 Dec 2012

As one of the a few Chinese players on LG, I'm more than happy to see the possibility that Xiangqi, one of the most popular board games in China (despite that the name "Chinese chess" might have prevented it from becoming a world-wide game as chess does), could become one of the games here:)

Other games mentioned in this thread should be fun too and all of them ideally should come into LG finally, so I guess the only problem is what comes next. Maybe we could run a voting for the next new game on LG?

#59 · Elsabio

17 Dec 2012

I relatively new ar LG, so my question: What means "new" at the game lables. I mean how often are new games implemented at LG?
I would welcome it To have Xiangqi here on LG because l have no human partner To play with.
I think if it is in principal possible To implement new games we should do two things.
Make a wishing list of all games we like.( In anew thread e.g.)
and after a while we can make we voting which game should be implementd. I think this is the only way To solve the problem.

#60 · Christian K

18 Dec 2012

new means that it is among the newest games that have been implemented. I guess we usually have one new game pr. year?

#61 · Ricardo (Santos)

3 Feb 2013

now, in times when the Chinese New Year is approaching... I think it makes to make a small reminder of this topic andbring it up to the front page again :)

This year the 13th World Xiangqi Championship will take place in Beijing.

Here a link to Susan Polgars BLOG about Xiangqi Some interesting comments....

#62 · Elsabio

6 Feb 2013

I think Xiangqi would be a good choice for LG, because it would complete the three most
important members of the chess family. If we look at the many n-in-a-row variants we have here on LG
it should be cosequent to implement Xianqi. A second argument that was already mentioned is that it would be very attractive for many people of the eastern part of our planet, who are underrepresentated here. And last but not least: the gameplay of Xiangqi is real different from wester chess and shogi, so we would gain a real new game.

#64 · vonraider

4 Feb 2014

I am new here, but I'm adding my 2 cents. Xiangqi is a great game and deserves to be here. Especially since Shogi already is.

#65 · Kerry Handscomb

5 Feb 2014

I skimmed over this thread with interest. Xianqi is certainly a great game in terms of its history, popularity, and in the depth that it has been studied and understood. It’s comparable in this regard to Western Chess. Given a choice, I would prefer to play Xianqi to Western Chess: I find it more fun, because of the fortress, canons, and prohibition on facing kings, but that is just a personal preference. Shogi’s drop rule puts it in a different class to these other two games, and it becomes something other than another chess variant. Shogi is as much a race game as a chess game.

But really, there are no many great games that it is fruitless to haggle over personal preferences. I would like to see games on LG from completely different genres. In other thread I suggested a checkers variant or one of the great mancala games. And then LG would be offering something genuinely different from what it already has, while honouring families of games that have immense geographical and historical reach.

#66 · mungo

7 Sep 2014

Since new games have recently been introduced, I think it is time to revive this thread. Still hoping for chinese chess to be implemented on Little Golem.

#67 · Ricardo (Santos)

16 Sep 2014

Now, in days of "where all the young games gone..." maybe there could be an opportunity for introducing Chinese Chess? Just after the celebration of the moon festival, the timing could not be better :)

#68 · Ricardo (Santos)

16 Sep 2014

... just taking the chance, before all posts might be gone as well...

#69 · Adam Szlachta

15 Nov 2014

I would love to play xiangqi on Little Golem. There was some time it was possible to play in a turn-based way on dualpose.I definitely prefer shogi, which is my favourite game ever, but I am personally connected to Vietnam, where xiangqi is main chess variant, like in China, and I have more opportunities to play xiangqi with "native" xiangqi players than shogi. I even have a lot of Vietnamese books to study xiangqi, but of course they require me to study Vietnamese first ;)Of course it would be the perfect idea to introduce janggi, Korean variant along with xiangqi. The games are extremely resemblant in rules, although the actual typical game play looks very different.

#74 · Ray Garrison

7 Oct 2017

would love to play Chinese Chess here.  Maybe Korean chess as a sub variation?

Last page