Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

Hex strategy book

Public forum discussion.

Hex, Havannah

#51 · lazyplayer

2 Feb 2019

For black territory, there are two definitions that make some sense to me:

1) All cells that can't be played by white without losing "obviously"

2) All cells that should not be played by black because they're "obviously" a waste of time

Earlier I had argued for using (1), but now I think probably the correct definition is (2). It's like captured and capture-reversible in the paper but with some added generality.

#52 · lazyplayer

2 Feb 2019

Hmm, but I see, (2) can't be right, because white can create black "territory" by adding stones... so I guess the only passable definition is (1), black territory is simply where white can't play.

#53 · lazyplayer

2 Feb 2019

Ehehe, but (1) does not have the property that black territory and white territory are disjoint. So, I submit another definition of black territory:

It's the empty cells that could be filled with black stones at any time without changing the result of the game.

#54 · lazyplayer

2 Feb 2019

Ah fuck, but this is again (2)... well, there is no territory in hex :D

#55 · lazyplayer

2 Feb 2019

Well, there is one way to make a definition that works, but it's almost useless: empty cells surrounded by black stones and/or black edges.

#56 · lazyplayer

2 Feb 2019

Actually, empty or non-empty, as long as they're surrounded, clearly they're black territory.

#57 · HappyHippo

2 Feb 2019

"Happy, the example is ok, but the text is not. You basically describe dead-reversible cells while explaining capture? Or maybe I’m wrong? I’m not entirely sure because I never looked into these details to be honest, although all my play is actually based on being very good at these local patterns :D"

I think I explained it correctly. Referencing the paper:

"Consider any pattern in Figure 5. Left has a second-player strategy on the uncolored cell pair — if Right colors one, Left colors the other — that kills the cell just colored by Right. Thus the uncolored cell pair is Left-captured." (where "Left" and "Right" are game theory jargon for "black" and "white," respectively)

In the book I write:

"Have a look at Diagram 236. Each pattern has two marked marked hexes. If White plays at one hex, Black responding at the other renders the initial hex dead ... We say the marked hexes are captured by Black"

#58 · lazyplayer

2 Feb 2019

Happy, right, I was confused on who is to play.

Black-dead-reversible means if black plays there, white can play there and kill black stone.

Black-captured means if white plays there, black can play there and kill white stone.

Damn the paper is hard, I'll have to take a few days to study it when I can.

#59 · mmKALLL

10 Feb 2019

Just checked this out in a bit more detail. Got immediately hooked and went through 5-6 chapters at once.

Fantastic book, really amazing work of you to put this together! I feel like I got at least 150 points stronger just by checking this book out. :)

Also thanks for the example games and template links, they really make this a special resource for studying Hex.

#60 · Giupiter

11 Feb 2019

I played a few rounds of Tanx Matthew and I enjoined it! I like the "scientific spirit" of the game, it seems to me like a tribute to Newton's law of gravitation :) COOL!

#61 · Korrun

13 Mar 2019

This is awesome! Thanks.

Last page