#1 · Tim Shih
23 Jun 2004
Very few people are chatting on this forum lately. Let me break the ice by sharing with you all an anecdote related to an amateur Go player.
Let us call him S. He was a very strong amateur player in Taiwan. An unwritten rule was such that any talented child, deemed promising in the future, must defeat S first, in order to qualify for being sponsored to Japan to further his Go study.
And S thought himself to be great, too. One day, Chen Zu3 De2, the first Chinese Go pro who defeated a Japanese 9 dan in 1960s, visited Hongkong. S happened to be in HK, too. Chen and S agreed to play a game. Chen thought S should have placed 3 handicap stones. But S insisted laying down only 2. Somehow S managed to win the game (the fact was that Chen was ill that day, had to go back to his hotel room to rest frequently, leaving S to ponder over the moves with unlimited time).
So, S’s confidence soared to the sky. After he returned to Taiwan, he ranted and raved about his game, published it in a few newspapers, and even commented on the moves.
Then, some time later, another Chinese Go pro, Nie Wei Ping who defeated many Japanese 9-dans in 1970s, visited HK. S immediately challenged Nie with a 2-stone game. He also requested an umpire, a game recorder, and a clock to make the match very official. Some spectators even did the betting on the game.
The result? Nie won the game overwhelmingly. He donated the winning money to the club. :)
Usually, there is very little chance for an amateur player to defeat a 9-dan pro with 2 handicap stones.