Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

Slow players

Public forum discussion.

General

#52 · Thomas Werner

17 Feb 2014

Hi,

*de-register timeout players from championships*
Sounds good to me. So what could be the condition for the deregistration?
My proposal: Timeout in any game of a particular championship triggers deregistration of that championship. (So any timeout in the Go19 championship leads to deregistration from the Go19 championship, but not from other championships.)

*start a new tournament as soon as promotion/demotion is clear*
This sounds partially good. I find it hard to implement such a feature, because the slowest players tend to have many unfinished games. This means that they can still gain many points and can end up anywhere in the ranking except maybe the top and bottom position. An important exception are, of course, the lowest levels of a championship, where only promotion needs to be clarified. Here, I agree that the tournament could be ended, e.g. by forced ties, when the first ranks in the lowest championship level are clear.

I'd like to make two new proposals regarding vacation days.
*more frequent replenishment of vacation days*
Instead of giving every player a certain number of vacation days at the beginning of each year (and also maybe during the year due to some technical issues), I propose to give a certain number of vacation days at the beginning of each month(e.g. 2 for puny earthlings like me, 3 for LG members). At the same time, limit the number of vacation days to 20 (or 30 for members).

*taking vacation only affects "due" games*
Instead of adding 24 hours to every game of a player who is taking one day of vacation, only add the 24 hours to games that have less than _N_ hours left (with N=24,36,48 or whatever threshold, currently we have N=infinity). The evident benefit is that you will have your 20 (or 30) vacation days, but when a player has used up all his vacation days in a row, there are no game

#53 · Thomas Werner

17 Feb 2014

...
there are no games with more than _N_ plus 24 hours left.

I have still one proposal.
*hurry up slow players*
Make the award for a played move in a game dependent on the "type" of tournament. Currently, LG has the "+36 hours"-rule for all tournaments (championship, monthly cup, rated game, unrated game). I'd propose to introduce a "hurry up" flag for championships. When _N_ percent of all games are finished (e.g. N=90), change the championship into a "quick mode", where the award for a played move is only +24 hours. This could speed up the end of a championship.

#54 · FatPhil

17 Feb 2014

I also like the earn-vacation-days-monthly idea. In particular if you don't earn them if you've timed out of any games that month. The moribund must be put out of their, or our, misery more quickly.

Different disciplines could have different time constraints, and thos time constraints need not be constant. Real world chess is the classic example.

#55 · z

17 Feb 2014

I have a somewhat related idea about vacations.

Everyone starts with %I hours of vacation. Each move is expected to be made within %E hours when it's your turn. If you make a speedy move in %s hours (%s <= %E), you accrue %R * (%E - %s) hours of vacation; otherwise, you lose %P * (%s - %E) hours. Vacation is capped at %M hours, and if you use it up, all games awaiting your move time out.

Suggested parameters:
%I = 36 (initial vacation hours)
%E = 36 (expected delay per move)
%R = 0.25 (reward coefficient)
%P = 1.5 (penalty coefficient)
%M = 240 (maximum vacation hours)

This proposal not only imposes a slow-move penalty but also offers an incentive to fast players.

#56 · Thomas Werner

18 Feb 2014

@z
I first felt comfortable with the reward for speedy moves, but quickly realized that it can be misused for deliberately delaying tournaments.

I dislike the concept of penalties, because:
The penalty part (with the current parameters) means that when, for example, you
- have 120 hours left in a game (5 days)
- can not play for 96 hours (4 days) and then make your move
your remaining amount of hours in that game drop from 24 to -6 due to that penalty. So you play in time and still will lose one day of vacation.

On the other hand it could be reasonable just to *limit the amount of games that can be played simultaneously* on Little Golem. I am mentioning this, because I currently play Go9 against an opponent who is awfully slow (and the game is already decided, in my opinion). He is making a move every 3 to 4 days in average, and is hence taking vacation days, of course. Why is he playing so slowly? He currently has these games in progess:
273 Einstein würfelt nicht,
56 Street Soccer,
45 Shogi,
21 Lines of action,
18 Go
and some others, so I understand that my opponent is quite busy.

By limiting, I do not mean simply limit the number of games. Introducing a weighted system (e.g. 10 points for Go9, 14 points for Go13, 20 points for Go19, and so on) together with a limit of the total points per player (e.g. 1000 points) could prevent an overload for players (if they do not resort to multiple accounts). This is roughly the policy: *An average player should not spend more than _N_ hours daily playing on Little Golem*

#57 · FatPhil

18 Feb 2014

Stopping poeple from signing up or being signed up for new events unless they've played enough of their moves, as mentioned above, helps keep some players like that more under control. 400+ games is pretty wild. I'm uncomfortable with more than about a third of that.

#58 · z

18 Feb 2014

+1 on limiting the total amount of active games.

On second thought, my earlier proposal is overly complicated and may be less effective at speeding up tournaments.

#59 · Kerry Handscomb

18 Feb 2014

The point is to limit signup when players have many games active when it is their move. There may be one or two players whose life is LG, and who can keep a thousand games up to date.....

#60 · Greck

18 Feb 2014

A long time ago I used to have 700+ ongoing games :)

#61 · Mirko Rahn

19 Feb 2014

I like the rules they are, especially their simplicity. I don't like non-local rules, e.g. making time depend on the status of other games. (Imagine your clock shows 12 hours, you go to sleep and in the morning you lost just because some other games are finished now!?) I don't like limitations like a maximum number of ongoing games. Not adding vacation days to all games is against the idea of vacation. Playing more than one championship at the same time is against the idea of championship, against the idea of having a single champion.

I don't like any kind of special treatment for people that follow the rules.

We could, instead, change the default and automatically de-register all players on tournament start. With other words: A subscription would be valid for a single tournament only. Seems to be the solution that is easiest to implement and could be agreed on.

#62 · Dvd Avins

19 Feb 2014

Instead of a pool of 240 hours, I like byi yomi time (AKA grace time). Give everyone 36 hours that gets refreshed whenever they make a move, but also a pool for each game of 204 hours (240 - 36) that doesn't get refreshed in a game. Change the numbers, increasing the 36 and perhaps decreasing the 204 if you want to accommodate players who have more frequently irregular schedules. But making the whole pool of 240 hour refreshable just encourages procrastination followed by stress, I think. Vacation would still handle real absences.

#63 · terrance806

19 Feb 2014

I don't see how restricting the number of games will necessarily make slow players move more quickly. It appears some players will always make their moves at the last possible time.

@Avins I agree a shorter time makes sense but there does not appear much support in the LG community.

So two other suggestions:
1) Have both fast and regular time tournaments.
2) Make vacation time opt in. You have to elect to go on vacation and if you don't the game is forfeited.

#64 · richyfourtytwo

19 Feb 2014

Opt in for vacation time is the standard on many other sites. That it is automatic here is one of the main reasons for me of playing here and not elsewhere.

#65 · Jonny

19 Feb 2014

is it possible to have a "real time area" on this side? So that two player can play in hours a 50 Point game?

May be it is a variant for fast player

#66 · jamjam

19 Feb 2014

There is a suggestion to add a vacation day every 18 days (up to a limit of 20 vacation days, newly registered players start with 10 days),

365 days / 18 days = 20,27 vacation days.
(Members get a vacation day added every 12 days)

It would not solve everything for slow players, but a newly registered player in e.g. November could not use 40 vacation days in a row (only about 10).

**
The other problem is in games like Go (or e.g. Havannah), they consist of many moves, which is the reason they can take so long.

Last page