For the February 1 section (the one now being polled) I'd most enjoy chess. But even more, I think we need to start some of the doubles: Reversi-8/-10; Go Moku/Connect 6; Hex-13/-19. Any others I'm forgetting?
Anyway, I'll vote for whichever part of some double gets traction in the poll.
I think you'll find that Wyps and GWG are less similar than one might think, Hjallti. Also, since the Wyps championship is played with words, the Tour version will be so too - at least that's what I assume.
I know they are not that similar but WYPS with numbers is much fair in my opinion. Did you see some of the black to play and win puzzles Richard himself posted in the Word Game forum?
I'll vote for hex-13 if it's between that and a non-double. But I'm not crazy about it, since the championship is about to start and I'd rather be playing different games.
why are there so many people in round two of the dvonn tournament? I thought only the winners go through to the next round, but it appears that all the 2nd place people made it through too.
Don't resign... let Richy42 start a new UT with the proper second round player (locked) and make it clear to everyone that this is where the points go. And enjoy the extra UT for the honour.
1) play the tournament, then at the end, award points only to the first round tournament winners based on how they placed relative to other first round winners (including the results against 2nd place finishers).
2) play the tournament, then at the end discard all results by the 2nd place players. Richy42 will have to manually construct a round-robin table from the results and calculate the tiebreaks, but this is probably the fairest way to do it.
It is tempting to just play the tournament as is, but it is an unfair advantage not only to the 2nd place winners, but also the 1st place winners because there will be so many points awarded in the 2nd round. The DVONN winner will get 26 points from the 2nd round - that's ridiculous!
I think I'm a 2nd place guy. I've not played any moves and am prepared to just resign them all if that would make things easier. Of course, I'd prefer to actually play the games...
Well, there was a group in round 1 with a triple tie for place 1 (IMO, I did benefit most, because of a very lucky win against one of the real champions) So there are even 3 (legal ;) participants from group 3.
I think it's not too unfair that we have to compete some more participants.
But round 2 participants really get lots of points, I agree with hammurabi. Richy might rethink his score system. Or do we misunderstand his comment on points for a tie ? (Aren't place 1 and 2 of round 1 treated as a tie here?)
I'd propose let's play all games and help Richy with opinions how to score them, independently. (I understand Richy is doing the calculations manually anyway ?)
And yes, I have asked Richard about this and suggested that the maximal groupsize and number of players advancing become parameters when setting up a user tournament. The answer I recieved was 'I will change it soon.' I don't know how soon soon is, but I hope soon enough for the next 2nd round tournament starting. Neither am I sure what it will change to, but I hope either to what it was before or to my suggestion (with the old numbers as a default).
I see having a stable user tournament environment as a requirement for the tour. The tour wouldn't make much sense (at least I wouldn't want to organise it) if we had to re-decide about how points are handed out every 6 months.
At the moment I am not sure if/how the tour can/will be continued. The way points are awarded rely on stable group sizes. Until recently we had max. 7 players per group. This suddendly changed without warning about a week ago. Richard told me privately that something will change soon. As long as I neither know exactly how user tournaments work today nor have any idea how they will work tomorrow it doesn't make much sense to start new tournaments. Handling the unexpected 2nd round groupsizes of tournaments already running will be enough of a burden.
Consequently I will not let the go19 tournament start on January 1st unless the situation has cleared up by then. Sorry for this. Organising the Tour costs me a significant amount of time, but it is fun too. I hope we can continue. If you know a solution without massive administrative overhead let me know.
I think it should be possible for an organizer of a user tournament to decide the maximum number of players in each group... that would solve the problems, right?
Anyone interested in voting for the Feb-2010 stage, should be aware of the discussion during the first december days in this thread here, starting with
Dvd Avins ... "I think we need to start some of the doubles" ...
Yes, that's how I planned it, sorry for not answering before. The newest einstein user tournament started with 7 players per group. I've asked richard if we can expect this to be a stable behaviour. So there is some hope we can move on.
I'm just guessing that we're with 9 because their was a 3-way tie in group 2 and therefore all third place finishers advance. Is this normal behavior? Never gave any attention to this really, but it seems strange to me. Anyway, I've not made a move yet and will not until I hear if this is the expected behavior or richy tells me what to do...
I got a reply to my message to Richard. Not neccessarily an answer though. He confirmed that now the first two players of each group are promoted to round 2. I still have no reliable information about group sizes and if we can expect the current state to be stable. On Wednesday I was in a fairly foul mood and was ready to give up the tour completely. Today my mood is slightly better. My new approach: Let's try to live with what we can't change. For the tour this means: We will continue completely ignoring all the problems arising from the changes in the behaviour in the past and future. The scheme for distributing points just stays the same, no matter how many players proceed or how large the groups are. If you want to tell me how grossly unfair that is to some players go ahead. But rest assured I'm well aware of that already. I just have better things to do in my life than constantly reinventing the tour. If the user tournaments stay stable from now on, so will the tour. If they don't, I can't help it.
I will let the go tournament start tomorrow. I hope I'll find the time tomorrow to start a new poll and update the website.
Sorry if this message sounds a bit grumpy. I still think this is a great site and I'm still grateful to Richard for giving it to us. But it's sometimes hard not to be frustrated about how much better it could even be if Richard were just communicating a bit more.
OK, thanks! I think this is a good way to go... Anyway nothing is perfect in this world, but as long as spirit is high it is fine anyway. Good work richyfourtytwo! Let's keep up and continue the tour. ;)