I'm just guessing here, but my guess is that "sandworms is fictitious" is the alleged inaccuracy, and that "words are generally getting longer" is the red herring, which leaves music as the true hint. But I'm just guessing.
hmmm...a difficult puzzle....a new hint is that Nathan has updated his list a few times recently by deleting his recent post (a privilege of members) and updating the list with new "but nots" This tells me that either the list is limited to these 28 items, or, Nathan can not think of #29....but this could be another "herring hooked" ?
I keep thinking that the members of the solution have nothing to do with the animal itself, but the word, maybe the letters, # vowels, scrabble value, or???
Good idea, but I don't think the language thing is it.
cat and dog are felix and canus in Latin, gato and pero (sp?) in Spanish, katze and hund in German, so for those languages, there's no indication that one of them would be on topic and the other off.
I looked at qwerty keypad locations, but didn't see a distinguisher.
I would be disappointed if the criterion involves Scrabble points, as Ray already did that. Nevertheless, if they aren't all the same Scrabble value, could it be even/odd or prime/composite Scrabble value?
Taxamonialy wise, I though I was on to something with weather there were sub species/more specific types of them or not, but it didn't hold up... I have a feeling it has to do with the words, but then why are they all animals? Was that just a red herring?
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs
5. voles
6. bears
7. walrus
8. horse
9. manatee
10. seal
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
I withdraw my earlier speculation that "sandworms are fictitious" was the one of Ray's statements that Nathan characterized as inaccurate. I haven't found any use of "sandworms" for real animals on Earth.
Nathan, please don't delete your old lists unless no one has made a comment. I think you added a "but not" (or two?) but we have no way to determine what you have changed, as you have erased the history of the puzzle. The puzzle is already hard enough!
As for "sandworms" that surely seemed suspicious to me at the time, and I have given much thought about Nathan's comment concerning one of my three "hints" as being a true hint.,..which one? not the length of the words (bee, deer, cat, snake are all short), and surely not music (that must be the "herring hooked" as Dog could be represented by Three Dog Night, for example, but "dog" is not an answer), so is the hint about the sandworms as a fictitious beast the true angle? Everything else on the list seems real enough....still completely stumped!
Meaning, a long list of longer words must be more helpful than the opposite -- or so I had thought! The Rosetta Stone is more helpful than a pottery shard. That is all.
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs...but not gymnure
5. voles
6. bears
7. walrus
8. horse
9. manatee
10. seal
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine...but not wolf
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
33. marmoset...but not capuchin
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs...but not gymnure
5. voles...but not lemmings
6. bears
7. walrus
8. horse
9. manatee
10. seal
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine...but not wolf
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
33. marmoset...but not capuchin
34. uakari...but not titi
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs...but not gymnure
5. voles...but not lemmings
6. bears
7. walrus
8. horse...but not donkey
9. manatee
10. seal
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine...but not wolf
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
33. marmoset...but not capuchin
34. uakari...but not titi
35. vervet...but not grivet
I propose a new rule: If any puzzle list gets to 50 items, then the puzzle author wins for stumping everyone, and has to reveal the solution and start a new puzzle!
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs...but not gymnure
5. voles...but not lemmings
6. bears
7. walrus...but not pinniped
8. horse...but not donkey
9. manatee
10. seal
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine...but not wolf
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros...but not elephant
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
33. marmoset...but not capuchin
34. uakari...but not titi
35. vervet...but not grivet
36. fox...but not oxen
37. tamarin...but not macaque
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs...but not gymnure
5. voles...but not lemmings
6. bears...but not pandas
7. walrus...but not pinniped
8. horse...but not donkey
9. manatee
10. seal
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine...but not wolf
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros...but not elephant
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
33. marmoset...but not capuchin
34. uakari...but not titi
35. vervet...but not grivet
36. fox...but not oxen
37. tamarin...but not macaque
38. humans...but not troglodytes
Note 1. and 3.: rat ... ...but not rodent
Strong evidence it's the wordplay of these names, not their meaning. Not that I have any useful idea what kind of wordplay....
Also, wondering about the recent hint, and what is that thing, I looked at the page source code to get the link to the picture, in case it helps any of you (it hasn't helped me):
no (working) ideas - but i'm enjoying the pics. wait! ..i got it; these are creatures that possess the ability to stare into the very center of your soul. that's the connection, isn't it? the soul-piercing eyes? :)
i've known psychiatrists who appeared less observant (but only slightly)
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs...but not gymnure
5. voles...but not lemmings
6. bears...but not pandas
7. walrus...but not pinniped
8. horse...but not donkey
9. manatee...but not dugong
10. seal
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine...but not wolf
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros...but not elephant
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
33. marmoset...but not capuchin
34. uakari...but not titi
35. vervet...but not grivet
36. fox...but not oxen
37. tamarin...but not macaque
38. humans...but not troglodytes
39. hanuman...but not langur
It cannot have anything do do with the animals per se, I think, and so I agree with Art that it must have something to do with the words. However, I fail to see any connection between the spellings, and also I get no clues from looking at my keyboard. Iâm starting to think it has something to do with how the words are pronounced. Which makes it difficult, as Iâm not really sure of the exact correct pronounciation of all these animals.
Something along the lines of âanimals pronounced with a higher pich than the family the animal belongs toâ? Iâm sure itâs something simpler, but perhaps someone else can build on this idea and get it right? âAnimals pronounced with an upgoing toneâ, perhaps? It seems to me, at least, that the animals that are included are pronounced in a somewhat âlighterâ tone than the ones that arenât, but that could be just me not knowing the correct pronounciation...
1. rat...but not mouse
2. mole...but not hedgehog
3. shrew...but not rodent
4. tenrecs...but not gymnure
5. voles...but not lemmings
6. bears...but not pandas
7. walrus...but not pinniped
8. horse...but not donkey
9. manatee...but not dugong
10. seal...but not dolphin
11. zebra...but not quagga
12. monotreme...but not platypus
13. wolverine...but not wolf
14. ichneumon...but not cranefly
15. nemertean
16. sandworms
17. elasmosaurus...but not plesiosaur
18. steneosaurus...but not longirostrines
19. saurischian...but not theropods
20. scolosaurus...but not ankylosaur
21. aurochs...but not ox
22. anaconda...but not python
23. roadrunner...but not duck
24. rhinoceros...but not elephant
25. marabou...but not flamingo
26. dinosaur...but not archaeopteryx
27. foxes...but not ferrets
28. monarch...but not butterfly
29. bee...but not wasp
30. deer...but not elk
31. cat...but not dog
32. snake...but not serpent
33. marmoset...but not capuchin
34. uakari...but not titi
35. vervet...but not grivet
36. fox...but not oxen
37. tamarin...but not macaque
38. humans...but not troglodytes
39. hanuman...but not langur
40. tarsier...but not monkey
This piscean, thinking that the other animals' hints have been too oblique, has decided to take a more active approach in pointing the way -- it also gives him an excuse to be a show-off.
Circles and squares ... hmmm. Incidentally, I notice that all the good animals have no descenders (g,j,p,q,y) in their name. Alas, there are a handful of bad animals with the same property.