Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

Reverse Empathy

Public forum discussion.

Empathy

#174 · Carroll

26 Nov 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (but not Fly)
14. Flamingo (but not Heron)
15. Beetle (but not Cricket)
16. Puffin (but not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (but not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (but not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (but not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake

#175 · maraca

26 Nov 2012

For a moment I thought animals with an even number of consonants, but this seems to be wrong.

#176 · Tellmarch

26 Nov 2012

I know, they are all animals that verify a certain property P known only by Carroll.

#178 · Carroll

27 Nov 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (but not Fly)
14. Flamingo (but not Heron)
15. Beetle (but not Cricket)
16. Puffin (but not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (but not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (but not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (but not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)

#179 · Carroll

28 Nov 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (but not Fly)
14. Flamingo (but not Heron)
15. Beetle (but not Cricket)
16. Puffin (but not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (but not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (but not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (but not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)

#180 · Carroll

30 Nov 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (but not Fly)
14. Flamingo (but not Heron)
15. Beetle (but not Cricket)
16. Puffin (but not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (but not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (but not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (but not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)

#181 · Carroll

3 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (but not Fly)
14. Flamingo (but not Heron)
15. Beetle (but not Cricket)
16. Puffin (but not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (but not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (but not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (but not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)

#182 · slaapgraag

3 Dec 2012

animals found in the Amazon (just trying)

#183 · Marius Halsor

3 Dec 2012

I think you can find a Fly almost anywhere (not sure about the Antarctic, but still...)

#184 · Carroll

3 Dec 2012

Hum no...

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (but not Fly)
14. Flamingo (but not Heron)
15. Beetle (but not Cricket)
16. Puffin (but not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (but not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (but not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (but not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)

#185 · Carroll

4 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (but not Fly)
14. Flamingo (but not Heron)
15. Beetle (but not Cricket)
16. Puffin (but not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (but not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (but not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (but not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)

#186 · Carroll

5 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)

#187 · Tellmarch

5 Dec 2012

I propose a new rule. After one month without a correct answer, the author automatically loses. It is then the turn of another player, and the answer to the puzzle will never be known.

#188 · Ray Garrison

6 Dec 2012

I had proposed a completely different rule on Oct. 25, namely:

"If any puzzle list gets to 50 items, then the puzzle author wins for stumping everyone, and has to reveal the solution and start a new puzzle!"

The rule was seconded by Nathan Miller

#189 · Carroll

6 Dec 2012

Well these two propositions are contradictory so one would have to chose.
I'll try a middle way between not revealing and revealing, as something came to my mind while discussing topology with Ypercube:

"Open" is closed and "Closed" is open. And as Yper said some sets can be both.

#190 · Carroll

6 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)

#193 · Carroll

6 Dec 2012

:) you mean any distance >0 makes an open set?
No that is not it.

#194 · Carroll

7 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)
29. Egyptian Goose (not Swan Goose)

#195 · ypercube

7 Dec 2012

Animals that can glide (and not necessarily fly)?

#197 · Carroll

11 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)
29. Egyptian Goose (not Swan Goose)
30. Pegasus (not Unicorn)

#201 · MrMoto

13 Dec 2012

Is stork good? Nightingale? The Flying Spaghetti Monster?

#202 · Carroll

14 Dec 2012

Only the Flying Spaghetti Monster!

If nobody opposes I'll give the solution this week end.

#203 · Carroll

14 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)
29. Egyptian Goose (not Swan Goose)
30. Pegasus (not Unicorn)
31. Burrowing Owl (not Great Horned Owl)

#204 · MrMoto

14 Dec 2012

FSM is good, eh?

How about the following: paper aeroplane? (Or paper airplane?) Boomerang? Roc? Superman? The Silver Surfer? Smaug?

#206 · MrMoto

16 Dec 2012

Hmm! Well, before you give away the answer, let's ask some more questions.

The good ones on the list all fly, or move through the air somehow. You've told us that earwig, tyrannosaurus, and unicorn are bad, but we have no reason to expect otherwise. Can you provide any examples of any non-flying creatures that would be on the list?

#207 · Carroll

16 Dec 2012

No you are right, no non-flying creature is on the list, there is also another criteria which puts the ones you cited off the list.
I must say paperplane, aeroplane and boomerang share this criteria but are not flying creatures.

#208 · Marius Halsor

17 Dec 2012

I find Smaug's appearance on the list interesting. That exludes a lot of possible parameters. Also, I find that "Swan Goose" and "Great Horned Owl" is NOT on the list, is interesting. These birds ARE capable of prolonged flight.

So with Smaug on the list, and "prolonged flight" ruled out, there can't be many parameters left to consider - unless one looks to metadata like spelling, I suppose.

Would a general term, like "Bird", be on the list? (I suppose it might, since "Bat" is). What about "Swan", since "Swan Goose" is not?

#209 · Carroll

17 Dec 2012

Bird would be, Swan is not.

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)
29. Egyptian Goose (not Swan Goose)
30. Pegasus (not Unicorn)
31. Burrowing Owl (not Great Horned Owl)
32. Yellow-Bellied Flycatcher

#210 · Carroll

18 Dec 2012

Maybe I'll wait for EoW in the end...

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)
29. Egyptian Goose (not Swan Goose)
30. Pegasus (not Unicorn)
31. Burrowing Owl (not Great Horned Owl)
32. Yellow-Bellied Flycatcher
33. Bullfinch

#211 · Carroll

20 Dec 2012

Last day...

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)
29. Egyptian Goose (not Swan Goose)
30. Pegasus (not Unicorn)
31. Burrowing Owl (not Great Horned Owl)
32. Yellow-Bellied Flycatcher
33. Bullfinch
34. Stymphalian birds

#212 · Carroll

20 Dec 2012

1. Parrot
2. Hummingbird
3. Scarlet macaw
4. Neotropic cormorant
5. Oropendola
6. Melodious Blackbird
7. Ringed Woodpecker
8. Jacamar
9. Magellanic Diving Petrel
10. Sparrow
11. Pigeon
12. Bat
13. Libellule (not Fly)
14. Flamingo (not Heron)
15. Beetle (not Cricket)
16. Puffin (not Auk)
17. Mobula Ray (not Flying Fish)
18. Common Snipe (not Snail Kite)
19. Maybug (not Earwig)
20. Paradise tree snake
21. Anomalure (not flying Squirrel)
22. Pteranodon (not Tyrannosaurus)
23. Magpie (not Jay)
24. Robin (not Tit)
25. Albatross (not Skua)
26. Brown Kiwi (not Ostrich)
27. Brushturkey (not Horned Guan)
28. Red-bellied Pitta (not Lovely Cotinga)
29. Egyptian Goose (not Swan Goose)
30. Pegasus (not Unicorn)
31. Burrowing Owl (not Great Horned Owl)
32. Yellow-Bellied Flycatcher
33. Bullfinch
34. Stymphalian birds
35. Australasian babblers
36. Kakapo
37. Black Vulture
38. Magnificent Frigatebird
39. Sandpiper
40. Hornbill

#213 · Carroll

20 Dec 2012

Thanks to all for playing, answer tonight (CET)

#214 · Nathan F Miller

20 Dec 2012

Something that /almost/ seems to work would be "flying creatures with a bilabial consonant (i.e. p, b, m)." But then, 'superman' isn't good -- perhaps because he is humanoid rather than a 'creature'. Also I'm uncertain about pteranodon, because the initial p is silent, in the English pronunciation at least.

#216 · Carroll

20 Dec 2012

Flying animals with kissing-name.

#219 · Carroll

20 Dec 2012

Sorry about Pteranodon if that mislead you, I’m not fluent for prehistoric bests pronunciation.

It comes from a French social game called "touche" ça touche pas, "touche pas" ça touche ; for which my English equivalent was "open" is closed, "closed" is open.

#221 · Nathan F Miller

21 Dec 2012

1. yule log
2. jingle bells
3. Ebenezer...but not Scrooge
4. ivy...but not holly

#222 · Nathan F Miller

22 Dec 2012

1. yule log
2. jingle bells
3. Ebenezer...but not Scrooge
4. ivy...but not holly
5. Donner...but not Blitzen
6. gingerbread...but not candycane

#223 · Nathan F Miller

22 Dec 2012

1. yule log
2. jingle bells
3. Ebenezer...but not Scrooge
4. ivy...but not holly
5. Donner...but not Blitzen
6. gingerbread...but not candycane
7. garlands...but not tinsel
8. bows...but not boxes

#224 · Nathan F Miller

23 Dec 2012

1. yule log
2. jingle bells
3. Ebenezer...but not Scrooge
4. ivy...but not holly
5. Donner...but not Blitzen
6. gingerbread...but not candycane
7. garlands...but not tinsel
8. bows...but not boxes
9. magi...but not kings
10. myrrh...but not frankincense

#225 · Nathan F Miller

24 Dec 2012

1. yule log
2. jingle bells
3. Ebenezer...but not Scrooge
4. ivy...but not holly
5. Donner...but not Blitzen
6. gingerbread...but not candycane
7. garlands...but not tinsel
8. bows...but not boxes
9. magi...but not kings
10. myrrh...but not frankincense
11. reindeer...but not Rudolph
12. ballet...but not nutcracker

Last page