Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

new breakthrough variant

Public forum discussion.

#1 · Elsabio

22 Feb 2015

Hi,I was thinking about a BT variant which allows draws and a, le's say, different strategy. Tthe rules are: the first stone which reaches the last rank gets 3 points, the second 2 and thethe 3rd gets one point. theortical endscores are then 6:0 5:1 ,...3:3,...0:6. I think the  tacticl considerations will change. What do you think about it?.

#2 · Christian K

26 Feb 2015

For me, the game is complicated enough already :p

#3 · JohnDoe11

2 Mar 2015

I think it is a good idea.. <img style="width: 50px;" src=""/>

#4 · edbonnet

13 Mar 2015

I think, in practice, we would play your variant almost the same way we are playing the current version;

as winning in Breakthrough means at least drawing in your variant.

Anyway, it's a nice idea and it might be interesting to try.