Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

1800+ rating Club

Public forum discussion.

StreetSoccer

#51 · tonywu

3 Oct 2004

suddenly, you need 1779 to get into top 10!!!

#52 · antkam

4 Oct 2004

congrats to Teemu, our newest member, at exactly 1800.

10th place now 1772.

#53 · Teemu

5 Oct 2004

Thanks!

But, well, my visit at 1800 didn't last very long.

I don't think anyone has mentioned steve1964 as a member yet?

#54 · antkam

5 Oct 2004

I don't think anyone has mentioned steve1964 as a member yet?

haha, talk about forgetting the obvious! :) steve's so good we must have all thought he had been an 18xx before! :)

#55 · Enrico

7 Oct 2004

1784 is already needed. A lot of players are very close to eachother...

#56 · tonywu

9 Oct 2004

now, there are 6 1800+ in top 10. i guess you need 1800+ on top 10 is coming soon. may be even in 1 days!!!

#57 · FC Schalke 05

9 Oct 2004

six players 1800+ (not regarding passenger, then 7) at the moment.

#58 · tonywu

11 Oct 2004

hm... passenger ending his experiment. but only able to put top 10 up to 1791. and not 1800+.

may be we still needed to wait a while. ;)

#59 · FC Schalke 05

14 Oct 2004

At this moment 8 players with 1800+ in the top ten!

#60 · Enrico

14 Oct 2004

And again 8 players in top 10 with 1800+! I join the 1800+ rating club too now.

#61 · firenze

22 Oct 2004

this is perhaps he first time that there are 9 players over 1800 points. and i am among them! (temporarily)

yippieeee!

#62 · firenze

22 Oct 2004

i think i am the 18th member of the 1800+ club, with a personal best of 1817 points. what are the personal bests of the club members?

by the way, you need now 1790 points to be in the top 10 -- and you have to be FC Cwali for that... :D

#63 · p_a_k_o

22 Oct 2004

I've reached 1800 yesterday and now i'm 1830 (my personal best)

#64 · firenze

23 Oct 2004

ok my personal best for some time is 1849 :D now start the moderate freefall...

#65 · Ronald Lokers

26 Oct 2004

After being 1800+ for the 4th time in my 'career', I reached a personal best of 1821 today but it only lasted 10 minutes or so...

#66 · Enrico

26 Oct 2004

My personal best is 1806 so far. A few days later 1805 to reach the 1800+ for the second time. Now a little behind scedule :(

But working on my way up again!

#68 · antkam

30 Oct 2004

congrats dopple!!

as of this moment, top 9 are 18xx, and the 10th place is 1794 Gerard, one of the best players here. lets hope Gerard will move up soon and make top 10 all 18xx!!!

#69 · Marius Halsor

9 Nov 2004

My birthday has come and gone, and yet (to my knowledge, at least) there has still not been a moment where all top ten players had more than 1800 in rating. Currently seven players are above 1800, and the next three are close. It can't be long now...

#70 · p_a_k_o

11 Nov 2004

Was in soccer any rating tournament where 4 players are over 1800?? Or maybe it will be a first tournament on level 9???

Now are 3 players who register in RT over 1800. We need 4th person with rating over 1800.Who will help and make first tournament in level 9??

#71 · Dan Mircea Vasilescu

18 Nov 2004

I will try a passenger experiment to reach the 1800 club; I hope I will not disturb you too much.

#72 · tonywu

18 Nov 2004

The first level 9 tournament already started at 2004-11-12 05:25

#73 · antkam

19 Nov 2004

Dan Vasilescu (silexu):

I will try a passenger experiment to reach the 1800 club;

I hope I will not disturb you too much.

Dan, you are playing very well. You are winning our game and it was not luck -- you definitely deserve to win that game with some very sound play. You're leading in last few moves and if I equalize it'll only be because I'm a lucky bastard. :) In short, there is no need for you to "cheat" to enter 1800; you play well enough that it will happen.

I objected to passenger's experiments back then, and I object to your proposed experiment now, for what my opinion is worth. I dont care that you manipulate your own rating. However, in the process you also manipulate (and artificially inflate) many other players' ratings when you finally finish your experiment. That has implications on several other experiments such as when will all top 10 be 18xx, when will certain other players become 18xx, will they feel well-deserved if they enter 18xx because of your artificial boost, etc.

Moreover, passenger specified a date for his experiment to end. If you dont have a pre-set end date, your experiment is worthless, because it will absolutely definitely happen that you cross 18xx if you cheat long enough -- there is nothing to experiment, nothing to test, no challenge, and it will prove nothing. So, if you must do this experiment, please at least set an end date that is very soon.

But back to my original point! Dan, you are playing very well, at least where I can see (i.e. in our game), and you dont need to cheat to enter 1800. Earn it the right way!

#74 · antkam

19 Nov 2004

(continued from previous post...)

Note that: since I expect to lose my game with Dan, probably within the next 24 hours, clearly I am personally not affected by his experiment. So I am not saying all this for my selfish purpose! :)

#75 · Dan Mircea Vasilescu

19 Nov 2004

Thanks antkam for your words. Actually I am not trying to follow exactly the passenger experiment. I will close most of my games even if I am loosing or winning. I will not close the one where with my move I surelly win. This games will not be too many so not many players will be affected. I put and end date for my experiment the end of this month or earlier if I manage to enter the club earlier.

#76 · Dan Mircea Vasilescu

19 Nov 2004

I want to mention also that I will close the games in the ascending order of opponents rating, so each one will not be affected too much. In plus I will not keep more than two games not closed with the same opponent in order not to affect him/her too much.

#77 · Looser

20 Nov 2004

My first 18xx rank ... :) Now I have 1800 and I like it.

#78 · Enrico

21 Nov 2004

Again there are nine players with 18xx. Alan needs only 5 points to make top 10 all 18xx!

#80 · Nevermind

24 Nov 2004

I finally made it into the Club of 1800. It is temporary, for sure, but tastes good. :D

#82 · Mac S

1 Dec 2004

I looked at the rating list and noticed tigis is at 1901 now... I think he may open the 1900 club! (I do not count passenger who reached 1911 or something during his rating experiment)

#83 · firenze

1 Dec 2004

yep, there are two people right now in the 1900+ Rating Club, passenger with 1920 (according to ypercube's records) and now tigis. please see the "Personal Bests in the 1800 Club" topic as well.

#84 · firenze

7 Dec 2004

here is my solution for establihing true and valid membership in the 1800+ Rating Club.

i think only those should be members of the 1800+ Club who have made it three times, and never fell below 1600 points in between the three occasions of passing the 1800 mark. an added condition is that only those could become members who have already played 100 games.

this solution could filter out manipulations and one-time lucky coincidences and favors long-standing excellent performances.

rules are always arbitrary, and we can negotiate a better arbitrary rule, but this might be a good solution.

(by the way, this rule would disqualify me from membership, which is only fair, as i myself had one lucky run only)

#85 · firenze

7 Dec 2004

here is the modified membership list, applying the rules i have just described:

FC Cwali

tigis

antkam

FC K6J

tonywu

Gerard

steve1964

Petr Trojek

p_a_k_o

Alan

hard to see from their graphs, but probably barely made it:

Teemu

joe

very close, but in the nearest future can become "full" members:

neptun

Looser

Goober

Mister_Marty

had a good run once or twice but fell down in between:

Enrico

Ronald Lokers

FC Malaj

Batman

Tore Sandmark

firenze

simon craddock

dopplefunker

Mac S

Nevermind

Indy

Krysztof

Nostradamus

passenger

i think this way common perception of someone's skill and evidence of his/her statistics are closer to each other.

make corrections if necessary.

#86 · FC Malaj

7 Dec 2004

this actually IS interesting, and your proposed rule does seem to work.

#87 · Tim Sharrock

7 Dec 2004

One case it would not work for would be someone who gets above 1800 and stays there....

#88 · Michael Engels

7 Dec 2004

No problem to make the triple->1800 without dropping below 1600. You just have to do the reverse-passenger-move like Nostradamus (first resign all your games you will loose and keep the games you will win in your queue). This will get you above 1800 without the great drop after it. Once you've mastered it jumping like crazy over the 1800-mark is no problem...

#89 · Nevermind

7 Dec 2004

As it has been said couple times, there is always a room for manipulation, but I do like firenze's idea because it greatly reduces it. And his sorting out the previous 1800+ club members does show a convincing result.

If Nostradamus stays over 1800 after his manipulation, dropping just below 1800 twice then go back, he deserves to become a club member. But he won too many too early, being eager to pass 1900, so he will not be able to remain over 1600.

#90 · rehakles

13 Dec 2004

That's a good monday morning and a nice start into the week for me - first time @1803.

It was a slow increase overall and I doubt that I can keep it for long ;-)

#91 · firenze

13 Dec 2004

congrats, rehakles! as soon as you make 1800 three times without falling under 1600 in between those three occasions, you will become a full member of the club. making it once is easy, staying there is not. i know that well :D

#92 · rehakles

13 Dec 2004

hm, what if I would not drop down below, but stay above? Than the "3times-rule" would not apply - anyway, that will not happen, because some games with the final rolls in progress I will loose in a short time.

Let's say, the noise of my rating curve just peeked above that border ;-)

And now for the serious question - what will be my benefit to be member in that club? Do we smoke big cigars and talk about politics? What are the prefered drinks? ;-)))

rehakles @1811 for short time ;-)

#93 · firenze

13 Dec 2004

well the benefits of full membership include a membership card with discounts on whiskey and cigar consumption, conversations with Mr Phileas Fogg, and the indispensable five o'clock tea.

but see, rehakles, you will go up and down 1800 in no time, just be careful not to drop down below 1600 because then you would lose your temporary membership card and may drink only diet cherry coke :D

#94 · rehakles

14 Dec 2004

Thx firence for the information - now I can value the membership. I was afraid of some california barbarians being also members. Fogg, malt and havannas are ok for me ;-)

#95 · Looser

14 Dec 2004

I pass a limit 1800 twice and once I have 1800. Does it mean that I am full member 1800+ rating Club? Because then I felt below 1600 once. Could you answer me, firenze?

#96 · Tim Sharrock

14 Dec 2004

Firenze's suggestion is, I think, that if you drop below 1600 before reaching 1800 three times, you must start counting the 1800 visits again. I don't think that many people have commented for or against adopting this as the usual definition of the 1800+ club... so I don't think it has been adopted as such. (I will find if difficult enough to reach 1800 once!)

Tim

#97 · Looser

14 Dec 2004

But firenze qualify my person to players which are very close. But I reach 1800 3 times (twice passing 1800 and once reaching 1800) After that I felt below 1600. So my question is if 1800 qualify or I must pass 1800 every time?

#98 · Tim Sharrock

15 Dec 2004

I would interpret 1800+ as "1800 or above", so yae, I would say you qualify as both a traditional and a Fireenzen 1800+er

Tim

#99 · firenze

17 Dec 2004

Looser,

right, although the resolution of the charts are very low, it does seem that you reached exactly 1800 points once in between two peaks above 1800. that makes it three, and you are happily selected as one of the very few who can have a five o'clock tea with Mr Phileas Fogg :D

by the way: watch Nostradamus and Barry in their recent trip to 15-minute stardom, and see if they can make 1800+ three times without dropping below 1600 in the course of their run ...

Last page