#51 · Quetza
11 Dec 2004
lines of action (LoA)
Public forum discussion.
11 Dec 2004
lines of action (LoA)
25 Jul 2005
It's been a little more than seven months since the last post in this topic. I thought I'd start it up again.
I'd still like to see the connection game Havannah implemented here, but The Game of Y would be fun too.
Note one difference with Havannah and Y vs Hex and Twixt... The two players in both Hex and Twixt have different goals, i.e. one player is attempting a connection from north to south, the other player from east to west. Not so in Havannah or Y, where all sides belong to both players!
Onyx looks interesting but I've never played it yet.
Quoridor has more depth to it than most people think.
25 Jul 2005
I guess you mean "plain" Y on a triangular grid, Ed. "Official" Y as sold by Kadon has three interior points which they call "pentads" that have just five neighbors instead of six. The board looks cool, but it would be tedious and difficult to implement here. And it is debatable as to whether this modification constitutes an improvement. The idea was to increase the importance of the points near the corner, so more of the board would be used during a game. But in so doing, the game may have become unbalanced. Even with the swap rule implemented, I would swap any initial move in official Y, even in a corner point (which now has three neighbors instead of two.)
All in all, both versions of Y play very much like Hex in my opinion. Maybe something more different (like Havannah!) would be a better choice here. BTW, triangular Y is available on PBMserv. There used to be a display bug in the graphics, but that has now been fixed! Any size grid is available. My handle there is chmeee (with three e's) if anyone would like to challenge me to a game.
25 Jul 2005
This one is multiplayer (would be pretty slow unless tighter time controls were enforced) and might be tough to implement (would require communications between players as part of game) as well, but Diplomacy is a great game.
Currently there are email games of Diplomacy, but if it could be implemented (well) here I bet many of the email players would come along to play it here.
26 Jul 2005
If multiplayer games would work, Risk would be fun.
26 Jul 2005
Diplomacy is simulataneous multiplayer, which would make it harder to implement than an sequential multiplayer. But I would love to see a site dedicated on turn-based simultaneous play. It would give a total different variant to Soccer for instance, where both players give in an action unaware of what the opponent does in the same action.
26 Jul 2005
maybe Richard can provide some "interfaces" that should be implemented in order to create a new game:
the images
a java script that is called to check if it is a win or not
etc.
and other games can be created buy other peoples
26 Jul 2005
I vote for Shogi and the card game Wizard.
Havannah and any game from the Gipf-Project would also be nice.
26 Jul 2005
Can anyone contact Richard and ask him for a statement?
27 Jul 2005
Lines of action is my vote.
30 Jul 2005
hex 10x10 at the littlegolem it's my sugestion
30 Jul 2005
Hex 10x10? No!
I love to play hex but we already have hex 13x13 and 19x9. We don't need another hex size. Furthermore, there are computer programs that play an excellent game of hex on that size board. Ideally, future games here should be ones that computers have a hard time playing. (Like Havannah, for example.)
30 Jul 2005
maybe yes but I LOVE 10x10
31 Jul 2005
Let's beat him up, Ed. Let me guess, 1024: You like to play 10x10 on Kurnik with a 3-minute time limit. Am I close? Or maybe it's 1 minute? Do you like to drink Jolt Cola? Sorry, that's none of my business. Is life something you want to hurry up and get it out of the way? What about the Meadowlarks? Ah yes, the Meadowlarks...
31 Jul 2005
japanese and chinese chess, backgammon, wari
1 Aug 2005
If the swap rule does not really work in official Y, how about double-move (official) Y. I've played it a few times at the local go club and it is quite intriguing.
3 Aug 2005
7 Aug 2005
I like to see like Anti-connect 4 or anti chess, its when u try to lose
7 Aug 2005
I think they should have Anti Connect4 and Anti Chess, Its when you try to lose :) Whats your suggestion?
10 Nov 2008
Just for fun, I'm bumping this topic (39 months since the last post!) only because on 9/21/2004 David Milne had a neat comment about Havannah.
24 Nov 2008
Pente please.
24 Nov 2008
Now that Havannah is finally on LG I think it would be fun if you could play "Chase" on LG.
24 Nov 2008
I think David's comment on Havannah reflects, at least in part, out lesser understanding of Havannah in comparison to Hex and Twixt.
24 Nov 2008
His comment from 2004, that is, not the one above me.
24 Nov 2008
Or if Pente is a problem, how about Ninuki-Renju?
24 Nov 2008
Umm... yes, I don't understand much about Hex or Twixt and I understand even less about Havannah :-))
25 Nov 2008
Shogi, please.
25 Nov 2008
Shogi and Trax please.
25 Nov 2008
Shogi !
25 Nov 2008
xiangqi (chinese chess)
25 Nov 2008
oware, shogi and chinese chess, backgammon
29 Nov 2008
Several of the regional chess relatives: Xiangqi (Chinese), Shogi (Japanese), Janggi (Korean), and Makruk (Thai).
29 Nov 2008
How about hexagonal chess which I understand is played by more than half a million people in Eastern Europe.
3 Dec 2008
Trax
3 Dec 2008
what about TwixT 36x36 or 48x48?
seems to be a big number, but i guess the average of the league nr 1 games is less than 30 moves per game (in chess counting it would be only 15!) I think we would have a much longer opening phase, which can be as short as 3 moves in TwixT 24x24 before going to the middle game, although you can't draw that line clearly...
11 Dec 2008
Gonnect is a very nice game. Its played on a Go board - typically 13x13.
The goal is to connect two oposing sides of the Go board. The Capturing rule and the Ko rule is like in Go. One fundamental difference to Go is that you are not allowed to pass.
Sometimes the game comes to a deadlock. Both players nearly have a conection, one player from East to West, the other one from North to South. Only in the middle there is a crosscut. In that case eventually players will have to fill there eye space. The player running out of eyespace first will have to fill one crucial eye and the oponent can capture and will proceed to win the game.
12 Dec 2008
I think Gonnect would be more elegant if you could pass, but the player who has captured more stones would be the winner if both players pass.
12 Dec 2008
Dvd Avins have you playedd Gonnect.
The original rules by the inventor did not have forced moves. Instead it had a bunch of special clunky rules to make sure the game worked. Then one day he noticed that if he introduce the enforeced move rule which elimated passing he could dump all the other special rules. This is why the enforced rule is very elegant. If you cannot make a move you loose. So now you can win if you make a side to side connection or if your opponent cannot make a move.
12 Dec 2008
I have played, but only once. I thought the endgame mechanics were clunky and too un-go-like.
12 Dec 2008
I'm glad to see someone else is in favor of Twixt on a larger grid. There may be practical limitations with trying to read a dense grid on a screen display. Maybe a more modest increase to 32x32 would be better. That would increase the size of the common playing area by about 86%. With the presumption that the average density of pegs on the board would be the same, that would up the average length of a game by the same amount. The opening would be longer, and grander schemes could be concocted. But of course there's still a lot to discover on the standard grid.
I invented a 3-dimensional tile stacking game called Lazo. I would love to see it implemented here. For those who have the software "Zillions of Games," Lazo is a free downloadable module called "Loop game," which was awarded special mention on the Zillions website. I have had difficulty explaining the game to many people, but this is a smart crowd, so maybe you would enjoy it.
12 Dec 2008
I like the endgame of Gonnect. It is un-go-like, I agree. But why should it be like Go? The only problem is, that the endgame might take many moves. There is a nice mathematical theory behind the engame of Gonnect. A rather straight forward application of combinatorial game theory.
13 Dec 2008
@David: I looked at your Lazo link.
From the Lazo description:
"Players compete to make a loop of their color."
If I place three of my tile so they "share a common vertex", is that a loop? Or is there some minimal size loop required?
"Tiles on the same level are adjacent if they share an edge." It took me a while to realize that two tiles "share an edge" if and only if they share a vertex. Maybe I've been reading too much graph theory.
13 Dec 2008
I'd say if you place three tiles that share a common vertex, it is no loop because there cannot be a passage for the opponent through.
Correct me if I'm wrong
13 Dec 2008
If someone places 3 tiles sharing a common vertex, then there clearly is a loop.
End of.
13 Dec 2008
I don't see the confusion. Three pieces that share a vertex form a solid mass. Topologically, there is no loop. The rest of the rules makes it very clear that that's what David's referring ton.
17 Dec 2008
What about Wildebeest Chess?
The rules are here:
http://www.chessvariants.com/large.dir/wildebeest.html
Two Camels and one Wildebeest per side are added. The camel makes (1,3)-leaps, as the knight makes (1,2)-leaps. The Wildebeest is the combination of Knight and Camel. A player wins by mating or stalemating the opponent. Pawns promote to Queen or Wildebeest only, because other promotions could only make sense for avoiding a stalemate.
But it is complicated to program: board size 11x10, more piece-types, more castling-options, pawns can make a double or triple step and can be taken en passant after leaping a square attacked by an opponent's pawn.
17 Dec 2008
The object of my game Lazo is defined on the second page. The first page is labeled "1 of 4." There is a link at the bottom of the first page to the second page, and so on. I don't mean to sound snide, but is this not obvious? Maybe I should make the link in a larger font, or put "page 1 of 4" in the body of text or something. Maybe I should glom all the pages together, what do you think?
There are two types of winning loops:
A board surface loop is a continuous path of your tiles, entirely on the board surface, which forms a loop around at least one vacant space or opposing tile. That means not only do three tiles of the same color which share a mutual vertex NOT form a loop, but three mutually adjacent tiles of the same color on the board surface which form a hole do NOT form a loop either. Perhaps I should reword this to say that a board surface loop forms a loop around at least one vacant space or opposing tile which is also on the board surface. The hole formed by three mutually adjacent tiles forms a space on the next level up, not on the board surface.
The second type of winning loop is a 3-D loop, which is a continuous path of your tiles, not entirely on the board surface, that forms a loop, either with itself or with the board surface, through which a continuous path of opposing tiles (and possibly vacant spaces) can be traced.
Another way of stating the object is, a winning loop of either type must have a hole through it which does not consist of any tile of the same color. This hole must avoid all blocking regions.
I define what a blocking region is in the rules. The pictures and examples explain what I'm talking about. I hope you will look at them.
17 Dec 2008
There's a second page? How did I miss that? Note: Don't feel bad. This is not the first time I've missed something obvious. :)
17 Dec 2008
If cells are vertices, and adjacent cells have a undirected edge between them, then *topologically*, there is a loop.
17 Dec 2008
Cells are not vertices.