FWIW this is the same system MindSports uses. I don't particularly love it, but I don't have a big issue with it either. It's functionally equivalent with the intended setup, so if other LG games work like this -- so can Tumbleweed, IMO. Really excited that the implementation is moving forward!
So, nobody tried to place a pie offer, and then select SWAP, and then play the first move?
Then setup a new game, place the same pie offer, and play the first move without swapping.
You would see that the first move is being played from a different position.
This is not possible because in Tumbleweed the position that "sees" the first move is determined by the pie.
If a Tumbleweed player tried this, they would understand it is not equivalent to the setup phase anywhere else.
I checked the Mindsports app and it is not equivalent.
On Mindsports the position that "sees" the first move is determined by the pie (just the order of stone placement is reversed).
Here, host places 2 stones (black then white) and then the guest has these options:
If white is advantageous, swapping black/white stones gives the opponent advantageous position + the first move. Swapping can only hurt them.
If black is advantageous, they already have the first move so swapping could only hurt them.
My bad, Alek is right -- this protocol doesn't seem equivalent with what Tumbleweed uses.
In Tumbleweed, the Host sets up two stacks: one (S1) for the first mover, the other (S2) for the second mover. The Guest then chooses whether to move first from S1 or second from S2.
But it seems like the current LG implementation makes it so that Black over has the first move. So unless I'm missing something, the choice for the Guest seems to be whether to move from S1 or S2; but they will always move second.
The reason why this logic works for Hex and not for Tumbleweed is that Hex's setup is a single stone pie while Tumbleweed features a two stone pie.
It can be fixed easily enough, though: if Guest chooses to swap colors, Black should automatically pass their move.
I think the same logic applies to TW and Hex. It is just implemented wrong for TW.
The Tumbleweed setup should go like this, right?:
White places a black stack and a white stack.
Black places a black stack or swaps the positions of the existing black and white stacks.
White places a white stack
Black places a black stack
Etc.
In Hex, it's like this:
Black places a black stone.
White places a white stone or replaces the black stone with a white stone in a symmetric location.
Black places a black stone.
White places a white stone.
Etc.
In both cases, the player who makes the setup offer is always the one who does not make the next move if the offer is accepted (not swapped). Since a different color moves first after the setup in TW and Hex, a different color must make the setup.
The Tumbleweed setup (in the original version) goes like this:
Host places a Red stack and a White stack.
Guest chooses whether they want to play as Red or White.
Red places a Red stack.
White places a White stack.
Etc.
If we want the players to retain the same color thorought the game, then it should go like this:
White places a White stack and a Black stack.
Black chooses whether or not to swap colors.
If Black chose to swap: Black places a Black stack, then turns alternate.
If Black chose not to swap: White places a White stack, then turns alternate.
@Zapala: I think it's equivalent. I just chose a formulation that avoids passing when not swapping and makes Black the player with more stacks on the board after every regular turn (assuming no captures), in keeping with the Go tradition.
@Zapala, in your formulation, the player faced with their opponent's pie offer must either perform two on-board actions (swap and place) or zero on-board actions (not swapping and not placing). In my formulation, all turns consist of exactly one on-board action (make a pie offer, swap or make a regular move).
In addition to having our notation system, we are used to playing with the corners facing east/west instead of north/south.
If it is not too much trouble, I think many of us would appreciate the board rotated a bit to match what we have been using for BGA/IGGC/Ludii.
Finally, in the most ideal world the black stones would have a tinge of red so that we could mentally relate our experiences with TW across platforms.
The 2nd Tumbleweed Championship will begin on October 24th.
It will be an online real-time play event. For each round, the players will have one week to schedule and play a match with their designated opponent.
All games will be played on igGameCenter.com, using 8x8x8 boards and 30’+30” time controls.
The format of this year’s Championship will be double elimination, meaning that you are out after two losses. The last player left standing will become the 2022 Tumbleweed Champion!
The initial seeding of participants will be based on their BGA ratings as of October 20th, except for the reigning Champion Anton Christenson, who will be seeded first by default should he choose to participate.
The registration will open on October 5th. Stay tuned for further details!
The implementation will be for mobile only and for the web app. On the standard web only iframe will be made. Which can be a bit limiting. For example, after making a move, the next game will not be shown automatically.
I'm not sure a I fully understand. Is the plan for the game to be eventually available on the standard www(non-app)? Or will it stay in app only (as incentive for users to use the app?) I'm not sure what "iframe" means. Sorry for my ignorance.
Hi, there might be a bug regarding the labels of who is what color, when a player swaps (or does not swap, I'm not sure).
In one of my games, I play with the Red stones but it says i'm playing White.
... all that said, the most immediate concern is the issue with passing. The rest are cosmetics which might or might not be important, but it's crucial for the rules to be properly implemented
I keep getting a message that says "Error: Token is expired" with an alarm clock icon next to (when using PC), then the game does not load. Is anybody getting something similar?
On mobile devices, it's best to use the native app. Yesterday's update natively supports 4 games: Hex, Havannah, Tumbleweed and Go. For the others, the web version of the game will appear.
I am new to this game, and it is not displaying for me. I usually connect via the website on a standard PC. I tried using the app on an android device, but the app never loaded. Is there something I can do to get the game to display?
For some reason, the is a long-ish pause before the game loads on my machine (about 10-30 seconds, I think). The page loads very quickly, and once the game starts to load, the it finishes in less than 2 seconds.
I reinstalled the app on an android tablet, and now I can see the game. I don't use apps on my windows machines and mostly just do LG through the website. There it still doesn't load for me.
Thanks for the response. Happy to get to play now.