Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

The (Un ) Affordable Healthcare Law

Public forum discussion.

General

#51 · Marius Halsor

17 Dec 2013

Norway has rather extensive healthcare for all, paid for by rather high taxes, and I think you'll find that Norway is still doing quite good. I'll admit that oil plays a significant role, too, but I think our system is even more important.

I think that two very important aspects mean more to Norwegian economy than oil: Trust and willingness to contribute. To explain why trust is the most important one would take too much time, and is also not that related to this topic. But our "willingness to contribute", a sense that we're all one nation, helping to pay for common goods like health care, also means a lot. Healthy people can contribute more back to society than sick people. Everyone helps share the burden (the rich more than the poor).

There are of course different opinions about this in Norway too, but it's mostly about the the degrees of taxation - not whether healh care should be public or not. And VERY few Norwegians would like to go as far as the American system. It is very, very foreign to us that you can be sent home from a hospital if you can't pay. The Nation should not leave its citicens to despair and doom, even if they are poor.

Having said all that, I DO agree that "someone has to pay". But to me, US taxes are way too low, and could easily be raised to cover the cost of common health care. Preferably with progressive taxes on income. The difference between a high and a low salary in the US is VERY much higher than what that difference is in Norway - and we have progressive income taxes on top of that! Now, don't get me wrong - there SHOULD be differences. Someone should make more than others, and making more should mean having a better life (in some sense). Only communists would think otherwise, and we all know how badly communism works. But the differences should not be too extreme. The relatively small differences in incomes helps build a sense of "commonality" - we're all Norwegians, and we're all relatively equal - which in turn reinforces the trust and willingness to contribute.

Well, these are my views, at least. Simplified for the occasion. And I don't even belong to the political left in Norway! :-)

#52 · mtbikesman

18 Dec 2013

The relatively small differences in incomes helps build a sense of “commonality” - we’re all Norwegians, and we’re all relatively equal.

Not so in the USA. We have been importing poverty on a grand scale for the past 20 years. The number of people needing services has exploded while the percent who pay for these services has markedly declined. We shouldn't have but we did and now we are stuck with a huge underclass that Norway does not have to deal with.

That makes all the difference now. Sorry to report, but it is true.

#53 · mtbikesman

18 Dec 2013

The cut/paste on this website has a few bugs.

#54 · Marius Halsor

18 Dec 2013

The "small difference" is not a law of nature in Norway either. It's due to our tax and welfare system, which is very different from that of USA.

The "needy" or "poor" need jobs and health service to make them - or at least the generation after them - productive and contributing.

I'm not sure how higher taxes and more public welfare would fit in the USA, due to the difference in mindset. In the US, it's "why should I give from what's mine to the poor and undeserving?", while in Norway, it's "why should someone be allowed to make ten times as much as others?", or "why should only the rich have access to health care, and not everyone?". I'm exaggerating, of course, but you get the idea.

#55 · elroy

18 Dec 2013

One of the unfortunate sides of a democratic system of government is the way that the electorate wants more services and expects to pay less for them. Many politicians will promise both of these opposing goals with no real ability to deliver them. This has been exacerbated in the United States of America by the growing acrimony of the competing powers in our two party system and by a media system that relatively recently has transformed into one that makes its living by allowing everyone to climb into their own little belief sphere. It makes it almost impossible for politicians to actually lead. They have to follow polls and opinion research based on an electorate that isn't actually being rational and isn't necessarily well educated in the nuances of what they are voting on. This is on top of the incredible distortion of Democracy that we have here due to the enormous amount of money that roams the halls of our federal and state governments because of the Citizens United vs. The Federal Elections Commission ruling handed down by the supreme court. Politicians are beholden to the big money that paid for their election costs. And if that wasn't enough, redistricting has made gerrymandered districts that essentially are strongholds of one party or another. This has lead to a situation in congressional elections where the hard part is to win the primary election instead of the general election and the electorate is so polarized that extremely right or extremely left promises have to be made to win the primary. After that, winning the general election is a piece of cake but they better not forget about those extreme promises they made or they are out of office come next election and someone even more extreme is in. Nobody is allowed to stand in the middle and support reasonable compromise. As Yeats wrote: Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold; Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world... What I am trying to say in my long-winded way is that there are some structural problems right now that are making it hard to fix ANY of the problems that we are ranting about here, namely big money in our political sytem and a profound lack of rational education of our electorate on the important issues of the day.

All of that being said...

It seems to me that our health care system based on for-profit insurance companies dispensing our health care is inherently screwed up. In my experience the roll of insurance companies is as middle men in cubicles whose job it is to refuse coverage for any reason that they can get away with, to create barriers for physicians to actually get paid and to make wealth for administrators and CEO's of the insurance companies. They get compensated very, very well. Why are we paying these assholes? It is insane. Does the reform we got fix this? Some. It was actually a compromise and it is far from socialized medicine. The single payer system that many advocated for might have been something like socialized medicine but that is not what we got with the ACA. The insurance companies had too much money in the fight and they still get to be the middle men. There are now supposed to be safeguards for the insured under the affordable care act. We will see if the insurance companies still find a way to screw with us.

#56 · elroy

18 Dec 2013

There is no doubt that our medical research and education facilities are powerful engines that produce wonderful technologies and skilled physicians but that doesn't necessarily translate into the best outcomes in the developed world. Unfortunately our medical outcomes are not even close to the best in the world if you consider how much we spend in comparison. The reasons for this are complex. One could consider the sad fact that way too large a percentage of people in this country are locked into an industrial food system that produces lots of cheap, food-like substances in pretty packages but little affordable actual food with real nutritional value. It tends to make us unhealthy as a whole. One could consider the amount of time your primary care physician (Family doctor, Internal medicine doctor, Pediatrician, etc.) spends just taking care of bullshit paperwork that has been thrown in front of them by the insurance companies in order to justify everything they do so they can get paid. Each company has different forms and different criteria and they change. Do not be fooled, primary care physicians work hard, long hours for the most part and are asked to do more and more with less and less autonomy every day. The list of issues goes on and on and sorting out the tangles in the system isn't going to be done easily here on a board game site.

#57 · elroy

18 Dec 2013

For those with an outside view of our system it may be easy to say that we just should start thinking clearly and transform the system into one like is seen in Western European nations for instance. It should be simple and sounds simple. It is not, and I suspect that many here can perhaps begin to understand this if my first paragraph above made any sense to them. I have a good friend who is at a prestigious university working in a PhD. program with a fancy title that basically means that she is learning what is wrong with, and how to fix the healthcare system in the United States of America. She said that some days when she thinks about all that she is studying she feels very hopeful and other days she wants to ball up in a fetal position and cry. It is a complex mess which will not be sorted out by quoting bumper sticker slogans at each other. There are people who are thinking hard about this with the best intentions of fixing it but there are also very powerful interests with a lot of skin in the fight who manipulate and distort the sytem for political and economic reasons. Decoupling those powerful interests from our political machinery would go a long way to helping MANY things work much better here. Sadly there is little or no political will to get this great task accomplished. Again I quote Yeats: The best lack all conviction, while the worst are full of passionate intensity...

@Marius Halsor: I wish that the citizens of the USA were able to demonstrate the trust in the system and the willingness to contribute that you refer to in the Norwegian system. Our two countries are very different though. Our country is vast and has regional and cultural differences that are truly challenging. When you combine that with the challenges I brought up in my first paragraph you might be able to see how hard it is for us to simply take your example and use it. I could expound on this topic but it would take up yet another three big paragraphs at least.

@Mtbikesman:

Our taxes in this country in real terms are relatively low right now and an adjustment to rates before the Bush-era tax cuts wouldn't be terribly onerous. Check out this web site for a quick and understandable view of historic tax rate http://qz.com/37639/check-your-us-tax-rate-for-2012-and-every-year-since-1913/

Probably the one greatest thing that would actually stimulate growth in economic terms (if that is your goal) would be for the banks to actually start lending all of the cash they are sitting on thanks to efforts by the Federal Reserve Bank to get money into their hands for this purpose. They are still scared and faced with a chicken or egg scenario. If there were signs of real economic growth they would start lending but to have growth there needs to be capital from lenders. It's a quandary we are still in.

Your statement “We have been importing poverty on a grand scale for the past 20 years” isn't clear to me. Are you suggesting that immigrants to this country are a drain on the system and provide nothing good or useful? You may not be, I am not sure. If that is your implication though I will suggest that this subject is also heavily debated and highly complex and that, as usual, the sides of the debate all tend to have an ax to grind and therefore a bias. I will simply point out that the entire history of the USA is one big story of immigration and the immigrants seem to have figured out how to help build the country in the long run. Immigrants do tend to be poor when they arrive though, I will give you that.

Now to check on my games...and maybe get some work done before I get fired and need welfare or food stamps or get deported to some socialist state with good healthcare.

#58 · Hjallti

18 Dec 2013

If the differences within the United States are to big, why does not every state create it is health care, which is basically what we do here in the United Countries of Europe (UCE). Note that we have problems with that as well, as in some countries there are 'minimal salaries' and in other (?less developped?) like Germany where that is not the case, and thus there is not an even playing field within UCE.

splitting up the system might be an idea, but if that works? What about Michigan?

#59 · mtbikesman

19 Dec 2013

I have Kaiser Permanente as my health insurance provider. With them I get good health care but not great health care. If I wanted great health care I would go to Cedars Sinai medical center where all the movie stars go. However I still get pretty good health care. Kaiser is a closed insurance program. I only go to Kaiser doctors and Kaiser doctors only see Kaiser members. (Most of the time, but there are exceptions)

The reason Kaiser can give good health care is that they are not burdened with the cost of treating patients who cannot pay. They only treat members who are already paying for their services (or their employer pays for it)

What would happen if all of a sudden Kaiser had twice as many members but all the new members did not pay anything for the coverage. I would get half as good of health care or I would have to pay double the premium for health care. I don't think I want either.

This is what has happened with social services in California with the flood of illegal immigrants. They arrive, illegally from central America and Mexico, and need medical care, and other social services. Yet they cannot afford to pay for it.

#60 · mtbikesman

19 Dec 2013

I arrived in California in the early 1970's and have seen California transformed from a great place to live (with a few bad areas) to a bad place to live (with a few good areas). It is true that the USA could always use some immigration but there are millions of people waiting to enter the USA legally. And waiting and waiting. People waiting to enter legally who have a good education and good job skills and are ready to become productive members of the USA workforce. The days of welcoming any immigrant with no job skills ended long long ago. There is no shortage whatsoever of unskilled workers in the USA

And the US is not the only country with restricted immigration policies. Actually, almost every country on the globe restricts immigration. Even Mexico, who is pretty damn hypocritical when it comes to securing our borders with them, but is far more draconian with their border enforcement on the south.

But for the past 20 years we have not enforced out own laws and are now paying the penalty for it.

#61 · scottygr8

19 Dec 2013

It is not just a problem in California ; Immigration has hit Florida , New York , Texas , etc .

( and my state - unnamed )

I challenge anyone here to go to:
New Orleans , Houston , Los Angeles , Chicago , Miami ( i e very big cities ) in America
and simply walk down streets at night. Then let us know how safe you felt !
@mtbikesman: I see it too - Urban decay - things transformed from great places to live to a bad place to live ( with a few good areas ).

@ elroy : You seem to suggest that this is all some silly game - I feel that our taxes ( since 1913.. )
are very very unreasonable. The system keeps 'propping up' all of the poor at everyone else's expense!
( the Middle Class workers and Upper class alike ) -
\*\* My main point is still : Why can't a government ( like a business !!! ) live ' within its means?'
If it takes in 2.6 Trillion dollars per year, then only spend 2.599 Trillion per year? Not in the once-great U. S. of A. Here, 'big government' spends 3.5 Trillion after taking in 2.5 Trillion dollars.
I am not speaking falsely ! This has put over 17 Trillion in debt ! Who 's going to pay for
this absurdity? **

#62 · scottygr8

19 Dec 2013

And now this very very inefficient governing 'body' wishes to overhaul our healthcare system?
Yet they tell us to trust them ?
It is for the 'greater good' of all ...

#63 · scottygr8

19 Dec 2013

@Hjallti : Each state does have its own healthcare system , tax system, etc.

\*\* Part of the Founding of the United States of America granted 'each State' the ability to govern itself
and the 'Federal govt. ' was given certain governing rights as well!
\* *

One Group has completely overstepped its authority - the System is being drained ......
see the Trillions and trillions in Red ink ! !

#64 · shalev

19 Dec 2013

@mtbikesman: Illegal immigration is a difficult problem. I think most people would agree that illegal immigration should be stopped (and controlled, legal immigration should be allowed to happen instead). The main problem, as I understand it, is that the US-Mexico border is so large that it is a difficult logistical problem to actually stop illegal immigration. In order to secure this border, the US would have to spend huge amounts of resources.

Let me make 2 more points on illegal immigration:

1) It is not as devastating a problem as you make it out to be. For instance, crime rates in California have decreased in the last 20 years:
http://oag.ca.gov/crime

2) The Affordable Care Act does not allow illegal immigrants to get subsidized healthcare, so it does not affect this problem either way. To get subsidized healthcare, I believe you need to file a tax return and have a social security number.

#65 · Carroll

19 Dec 2013

It is amusing and despairing the difference in tone between people thinking about systems and society and people thinking just about how the system should serve them. I can read me, me, me, my money, my money, my money...

Just think about a day in your life for everything that comes from the work of people who are not wealthy, and do need health care also and will get children that will need care too...

You are not in a separate planet living in a close circle between good people like you just paying and profiting from a good system without the need to handle these expensive poor people who should take care of themselves and live to their means.

It is the contrary, you are the ones who benefit from the work of other people, open your eyes! No that will not suffice, open your heart!

#67 · Carroll

19 Dec 2013

And speaking about paying for a system, It is not unaffordable for most of us to get a star here instead of just profiting from the work of one person, or should I play and speak only with stared people?

So I will stop contributing to this forum.

#68 · elroy

19 Dec 2013

Good point Carroll. I have not contributed my membership to LG in a long time. I will have to do that now.

#69 · Marius Halsor

19 Dec 2013

@elroy: Yes, Norway and USA are very different in many aspects. And I'm not suggesting that our solutions would be the best solutions for you - in fact, I doubt they would, if you tried to implement them "as is".

However, I DO believe that USA should have a higher tax level, and that this could help pay for some form of public health care. Note that I do not know the specifics of the proposed system, but I believe that SOME form of public health care would be advantageous. I agree that someone has to pay, but honestly believe that the rich and upper middle class of USA could and should do so. I realize that this may be an "unamerican" thought, but since I'm not an American, that's fine :-). It was the view of us in "socialist" (*laugh*) states that was asked for.

Immigration can cause problems (in Norway too), but I think that issue should be handled separately. A nation SHOULD take care of its own citizens, in my opinion. We may have gone too far in that direction in Norway (I haven't mentioned the downsides of our system yet), but I think that USA has not gone nearly far enough.

#70 · Marius Halsor

19 Dec 2013

And Carroll: I just noticed that my membership had expired. Thanks for reminding me - I've already paid for a new year. I wish I could pay for "lifetime membership", so I didn't have to remember this every year :-)

#71 · alain

19 Dec 2013

@Carroll: Good comments, it is very natural (when things go well) to say "It was my hard work and skills" and (when things go badly) to say "Someone else is to blame". While certainly somewhat true, life is not so simple since no man is an island. There are many superbly talented and hard-working Africans who will never get anywhere in life because the odds stacked against them are harsh.

@elroy: Thank you for your nice synopsis. It is a reminder to us all that our diversity is also part of our strength. I wish your friend success in her studies.

In the run-up to Christmas, is it such a bad thing to remember to open our minds and our hearts? Wishing all happy holidays.

#72 · Thomas Werner

19 Dec 2013

I share the view of shalev and Carroll.

I agree with shalev:
People without a permission to stay in a particular country usually do not have a place of residence there (how could they?) and thus simply can not apply for any benefits from the social security system.

I agree with Carroll:
Many people have the opinion that they should be revenued for the hard work they are doing, and that nobody else is entitled to gain from this. These people are furiously defending their point of view with various arguments mostly related to some sort of "getting-what-you-deserve".

In my opinion the tragedy of the US health care system is very clearly displayed by the honest statement of mtbikesman that he is glad to be in a closed health care system. I hear also a vibration of "I deserve this level of health care" in his post -- since he is rich enough to have Kaiser Permanente, but not enough for Cedars Sinai.

Social security, and health care is only one part of it, is a "common". This implies that you can not govern it by undergraduade economics. There is no price tag on "I am feeling comfortable today", "My back is not killing me anymore" or - as you might also label it more generally - the "pursuit of happiness". Pooling the happier ones together just means, that you are stealing from a common good without giving enough back to the community.

I personally have (as of today) a good job, good education and a good health. Many others don't. I can give back to the community and feel obligated to do so. (Americans can maybe relate to similar statements of the Governator, who is not a "native" American, of course). But when pazing taxes and social security insurance, my first thought is not that I am paying too much and that I am blaming others that they do not contribute enough.

Instead I am well aware of the fact that the "happiness I have already pursued successfully" is not purely due to my personal virtues. My wealth is based on the toil and suffering of many other persons (e.g. slave-like labourers in Chinese factories who have to produce your latest smartphone as cheap as possible), and I feel the obligation to repay the less happy in some way through
- progressive tax
- free health care
- free education

Illegal immigration is partially caused by not paying proper money for proper work of off-shored manufacturing. This simple fact may surprise some of the persons that read my post up to here.

You may have a different opinion on this, but be aware of the fact that social tension can escalate to street crime, civil war, organized raids of homes - and that there is no god-given natural law that provides you the right of private property. Having a private security service sneaking around at night and making your home saft is nothing else than a strong indicator that something is terribly wrong, because you have to pay somebody for not getting hurt or killed.

#73 · alain

19 Dec 2013

@scottygr8 and @mtbikesman: Something to consider is that someone, perhaps living in poverty and/or persecution, who can take that life-changing step to leave everything behind (including family and friends) and undertake a hazardous journey in the (possibly vain) hope of a better life somewhere else may actually be the sort of person the US should welcome. In the long run, that "can-do" attitude is what has made America great. You'll find plenty more born-and-bred Americans living off your hard-earned tax dollars than you will illegal immigrants! :o)

#74 · elroy

19 Dec 2013

@scottygr8 I am not sure where you got the idea that I think this is some sort of game. This seems like a strange statement to me but that is nothing new. Thanks for your passionate intensity though.

I wish I could continue on here for reasonable debate but reasonableness takes thought and long consideration and right now I have no time for either. I will have to help solve the problems of the world another day but I just wanted to say that I appreciate the thoughtfulness of alain, Thomas Werner, Marius Halsor, mtbikesman, Carroll, shalev, Hjallti, and pfafulous. Meaningful conversation can help us get a broader view and that always helps us all. Enjoy the season everyone.

#75 · Thomas Werner

19 Dec 2013

Thanks, elroy - and everybody else here.

Enjoy this time of the year.

#76 · scottygr8

19 Dec 2013

@ elroy : perhaps I read a few comments & thought they were yours / Was late when I last
read this info.
( sorry , if I was mistaken ).

@alain
\*\* I agree , there are thousands here who started with 'nothing' and earned livings the hard way! I know one who slept on buses for weeks / now he owns 2 businesses !
And yes, we call 'those born-and-bred Americans' freeloaders - many , many want
something for nothing ... **

( ahh , see those Social Studies teachers and/or History professors - - - As of 2012 , less than 50% of our population works / yet they support the rest ! )
\*\*\*\* This was predicted back in the early 1970s - - - these figures include 'the Poor' , the elderly , etc )
The 'Baby - Boomer' group in America (born betw. 1946 to 1964 ) are now aging! These years may not be totally correct, but I am part of that group.

#77 · pfafulous

19 Dec 2013

Wow, some excellent posts in here, thank you everybody for chiming in.

I think this issue will not be solved in the US for a long time, because so far there is much disagreement about whether health access for everybody is even desirable in the first place. Since there's so much disagreement on what "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" even means, then of course we won't be able to work together to achieve it.

That, and of course, the not insignificant fact that the "two-party" system is really a one-party system, and the government as a whole is beholden to big business and the military-industrial complex.

When you're among the super elite of the world, the average person is nothing more than one in a sea of hundreds of millions of interchangeable faces. We simply don't matter to them. They have all the resources, money, and power. Nations come and go.

#78 · mtbikesman

20 Dec 2013

Shalev,
Again I ask how bad does it have to be to be considered that bad? Since the 70's the school districts have become terrible to the point that the vast majority of LA teachers send their children to private schools. They know how bad they have become. Illegal immigrants (not legal ones) do not have the same cultural values regarding education and thus misbehavior and defiance have become bywords for the public schools in LA. And that is why charter schools are popping up all over. Most good students will do anything to get away from the now horrible public schools in LA.

And you surely must not live in LA. While illegal immigrants may not apply for Obamacare they surely can and do apply for local welfare to the point that it breaking the local budgets. Now streets and highways languish and are among the worst in the nation where they use to be the best in the nation.

Once more, how bad does it have to be to be that bad?

Also, while I do feel for those living in squalor outside the USA that does not mean we should let everyone outside come inside just to help them. Things are tough all over and we are not in a position to save them. I don't see Europe sending cruise-liners over to south and central America to shuttle them all to their countries to help them out. No, they are enforcing their own immigration laws as we should also be doing.

#79 · shalev

20 Dec 2013

mtbikesman, I concede that I don't know how bad the illegal immigrant problem is in LA. I agree that illegal immigration is a bad thing (legal immigration can be a very good thing, of course). I also agree that it isn't really the USA's moral obligation to help illegal immigrants - I would prefer the US to spend its foreign charity efforts on people who are even worse off, like those in malaria-ridden parts of Africa.

In other words, I pretty much agree with you. To anyone who disagrees, consider this: if the US took the money it currently spends providing for illegal immigrants and instead used it to buy mosquito nets for children in Africa, a lot more lives would be saved. This means providing for illegal immigrants is an inefficient form of charity.

Anyway, as I said before, the problem with illegal immigration in the US is that it is extremely difficult to solve logistically; a lot of money would need to be spent for this problem to go away. I'm not sure whether this is worth it - someone needs to do a cost/benefit analysis.

#80 · mtbikesman

20 Dec 2013

It is impossible to totally seal the border between the USA and Mexico. Many come here with a tourist visa and simply never go back home. However, a far stronger effort on our border would certainly curb the illegal crossings.

Also, nobody would stay if they could not get a job. However, the administration refuses to enforce our current laws and substantially fine all companies that hire illegal immigrants.

Thus when you have 20 years of failure to enforce the immigrant laws, as opposed to almost everyone other country, you are stuck with a big big problem.

#81 · shalev

20 Dec 2013

To get back to the healthcare topic, I want to explain the Affordable Care Act to some of the non-Americans on this thread.

First of all, this healthcare reform law already passed, and is put into effect starting in 2014. This is not something hypothetical the US is considering; it already happened.

Also, this is NOT a single-payer system - the US government is not paying for everyone's healthcare with tax money. Instead, healthcare still goes through private insurance companies. The only difference is that there are now laws in place to prevent insurance companies from screwing over customers. In particular,
\* Insurance companies are not allowed to refuse a customer due to pre-existing conditions
\* Insurance companies must provide insurance packages which meet some minimum standards (they can't say "oh, cancer? We don't cover that").

Now, if this was the entire law, then insurance rates would go up, because high-risk people will all get insurance. This increase in rates might cause healthy people to decide they don't want insurance and drop out, increasing rates further, etc. To prevent all this, something called an "individual mandate" was put in place. This basically means everyone MUST buy insurance or pay a fine, which forces healthy people to get insurance (and allows insurance companies to decrease rates).

This is still not the entirety of the law, because some low-income people won't be able to afford this mandated insurance. For those people, the cost of insurance is subsidized by the government.

The net result is that insurance rates will go down for most people, but go up for some healthy, wealthy people. The cost to the government will also increase. Overall, most economists predict that this will result in a more efficient system with less money wasted (it is well-known that before the reform, the US had one of the least efficient healthcare systems in the world). Some economists say that a single-payer system would be more efficient still, but this is not politically possible in the US.

#82 · klaashaas

20 Dec 2013

@shalev The Affordable Care Act sounds very similar to the Dutch health insurance system that we have for something like 10 years now. We pay about €1200 for the base-package, with a €350 deductible.

#83 · Hjallti

20 Dec 2013

@Scotty: I don't understand why you keep on confusing two topics. It seems like you are saying:

"We cannot choose for the cheapest solution, because we have spend to much money in the past"

That is like in a go, dot's or chess game in the following situation: you are behind on pieces, a certain offer of pieces would give you a much bigger gain and getting your game back on track (a bit) and saying:

"I cannot make that offer because I am already loosing".

I really don't see the reason why you bring this up.
Granted some oil company family has costs the states trillions, while there company made big money. (Raising oil prices during both the Bushy-Gulf Wars). It would be nice if that money was given back to the states, but this has nothing to do with the health care law.

#84 · scottygr8

21 Dec 2013

@Hjallti : the question here is 'who' is confused ?

'Who' told you about this 'so-called ' cheapest solution? Did Nancy Pelosi ?

Many here in this country have been deceived about another so-called 'inexpensive' solution....

( yes this healthcare law has passed , but ask most Democrats- in political office now about
the many, many problems / this 'Law' still has not been accepted - even staunch Obama backers
say it will not succeed ).

#85 · scottygr8

21 Dec 2013

Ask yourself ( Shalev ) this question:

If you are between 21 and 30 , will you pay a 90 dollar fine ( a new tax ) or will
you gleefully pay hundreds per month in premiums for this insurance ?
Most will choose the tax penalty - a once a year fee !

Also, these 'New' minimum standards for Ins. companies are already 'causing' rates
to rise / Research this yourself !

You are entirely wrong in saying ..... the Net result is that rates will go down for most people ...

( I suppose we shall see in the next 2 to 4 years. )

#86 · Ray Garrison

21 Dec 2013

The fine is $95 or 1% of your income, which ever is higher. So if you only make $9500 a year, your fine is cheap, but if you make that little, you should be able to get fully subsidized. In 2015, the fines increase to $325 or 2%, and in 2016 $695 or 2.5%, then the year after that, it is "adjusted for inflation" according to healthcare.gov

#87 · Marius Halsor

21 Dec 2013

Well, you asked about the opinions from us living in "socialist states" (*laugh*). Seems like most of us thinks som sort of public helath care is a good idea. I, at least, am VERY happy that we have our system in Norway, and not the US system.

I suppose the details about how it is administered DOES matter, but the important thing is that you get a decent public health care. It seems to me like a tax funded system would be easier and cheaper, but I don't know enough about your "insurance company administered" system to be sure. I guess that's the "American way".

#88 · pfafulous

22 Dec 2013

Scotty, I don't think anybody dosagrees that the ACA has many problems. That's not really the discussion. The question is whether it's the responsibility of a government of, by, and for the people to ensure that every citizen have access to affordable health care. The rest of the world says "yes".

BTW, the ACA is based largely on the Republican's proposal in the 90s, and Romney's plan in Massachusetts.

#89 · Knyx

22 Dec 2013

@scottygr8 It's actually not very clear whether the ACA helps or hurts with costs. It seems to depend on who you ask and how you look at it. Politifact (which I believe does a good job of keeping unbiased) has a good article on it: http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2013/may/16/nancy-pelosi/nancy-pelosi-says-obamacare-bringing-down-health-c/

Certainly there are good arguments to be made either way, but I feel like the only thing that is entirely clear is that nothing is entirely clear.

#90 · mtbikesman

22 Dec 2013

Pfafulous, go to USC medical center and you will find hundreds of people getting free medical care every day at the cost of the government. The same happens everywhere across the country. The question is how good of medical care should people get at the cost of the government.

The real question is how equal should medical care be for the poor vs the middle class vs the wealthy. The wealthy will always get great medical care no matter what. So it is the middle class who will go downward if the poor are going to go upward. Many middle class aren't happy with that.

Don't be a fool in thinking that everybody will get good medical care. There isn't enough money for that. Especially since the USA has been importing poverty on such a large scale over the past 20 years.

#91 · pfafulous

22 Dec 2013

I realize the US has a horrible system, and it will take a generation to fix.

I only maintain that it's a duty of government to provide access to regular health care to its citizenry. I point out that almost the entire rest of the world has done it, and at a per-capita cost lower than the US current achieves.

Yes, the US is broken. But if the US is so great, why can't they buckle down and figure out the best way to do it? They put a man on the moon. This isn't a matter of "can't" it's a matter of "won't". I don't accept that the answer is that you're not good enough to figure it out. There are many successful models from which to learn. You just refuse to do it, because you don't see it as a worthwhile project.

Even Amnesry International condemns the US on this topic.

#92 · mtbikesman

22 Dec 2013

Don't blame me. Nobody I vote for ever wins anything.
I think I am going to stop voting and just play Twixt and mountain bike until I die and ignore everything else. The last guy I liked was Ronald Regan.

p.s. How did Amnesry ever get past spell check ;)

#93 · scottygr8

24 Dec 2013

@ Knyx : your last statement sums it all up best!

This is precisely ( my problem ) with most of government - no matter which side you
back ! It seems both are very misleading to us all.
One thing is certain - I am paying more for everything in
2013 - ACA is a very misleading term.

#94 · David Milne

25 Dec 2013

I notice a pattern where people talk about half a thing, without even a whisper about the other half.

I heard some impassioned statements about California sinking under the load of myriads of illegal freeloading immigrants. I did not hear a whisper about the the voter referenda that where carried out over a period of years banning any tax rises. As an outsider I found this rather bemusing. First pick what you will pay, and then chose what benefits and services you want. Usually, in other parts of the world, it is the other way around. First chose what you want, then make a budget to pay for it. Anything else would seem to invite great problems. And California has great problems now.

#95 · mtbikesman

25 Dec 2013

California is now considered the worst run state in the nation. The legislator would spend spend spend while driving the tax base into other states. It is also the bluest state. It also has the most lopsided makers vs takers ratio.

But don't blame me. Nobody I vote for ever wins.

#96 · Hjallti

25 Dec 2013

@scotty

I don't understand why you are replying to this subject if you don't even listen to any explanation:

"( I suppose we shall see in the next 2 to 4 years. )"

The net return in the sense you see the whole picture will not be clear in 2 to 4 years: I am happy that I have been paying those ewxtra fines ever since I am getting paid (about 18 years now) because from that money (paid by others) my scolarship was paid as well.... but not in your country.

I am also happy that I can still am convinced that I personally will have lost by the system: it means I am healthy!

#97 · scottygr8

10 Jan 2014

No , I listen & read all - I also find it amusing that you place ' a few trillion dollars in cost ' solely
on Oil company families ( is this Bush & Cheney ? ) / Yet, the fact is we did face close to 8 trillion dollars of 'red ink' debt from 2000 to 2008 / Yes, two wars , possibly several major hurricanes, etc.
added to our debt ( please see Katrina , Rita , Ike , Gustav,... )
But since then, why has the debt soared to over 17 trillion dollars ? And, by leaps and bounds since 2008 ?
Did you know that the years between 2008 and 2013 this debt climbed at a greater pace than during any other time period in the past 120 years ? So what shall pay for this mismanagement & reckless spending/printing of money?
Yes , it is the next 2 to 4 years ( perhaps longer ) when all 'real costs' are passed down-the- line / hell yes, many of us in this country are fed up with it all !
( certainly , I for one , have lived a healthy life / so in your mind I have .....lost by the system .... our government systems are a load of crap / )

#98 · scottygr8

10 Jan 2014

Yet we are to trust that this 'cheapest solution' will actually be cheaper ? ?

#99 · David Milne

12 Jan 2014

The cheapest solution is actually cheaper, because it is "all ready paid for" over the years, out of the taxes of people, who for their first forty years of life, hardly had need of a hospital.

#100 · scottygr8

30 Jan 2014

Actually , it should be 'already paid for ' ........
but herein lies the great debate !

( once again we are back to
simple mathematics - - ' if a country takes in 3.5 trillion dollars in taxes yet
spends 4.3 trillion each year .......... )
..... then how long before .....' solutions like this ' bankrupt,,,,

#101 · mtbikesman

30 Jan 2014

Scotty, you are right but the people voted in an administration who wants to use the government to redistribute wealth. Now all they are going to get is a bankrupt economy. The fools! I don't even feel sorry for them. They brought it upon themselves.

How you spend money can be debated. How much you spend should not. Just keep it slightly under the revenues.

Last page