Public forum discussion.
10 Jun 2011
@Aganju: before we even got there, we would have to break the potential words up into two parties and hold primaries/caucuses (with different rules for each party and in each state) to pick some of the delegates (not the superdelegates, though. They get to vote for whoever they want) who will narrow the words down to two candidates. THEN we can start your process.
10 Jun 2011
@kpato: the thread startet just with a question: "Is cigarette brands really an appropriate empathy topic, for a "family site"?"
Is this "disrespectful" in your opinion?
Kitaktus
11 Jun 2011
@kpato - in the given example, that vote would indeed represent 100% of the "democratic votes" but hardly a representative subset of the PLAYERS (as in your original 50%+1 statement phrasing).
@all GOErs - I do see the point of the rule "do NOT discuss an ongoing game topic". On the other hand, someone quoted "freedom of speech" to defend the "cigarette brands" choice. Now, how on Earth, can we use freedom of speech to justify something and then some other one "Shut up! Keep your opinion to yourself until we're ready to hear it"?
My proposed middle ground: if you ever feel that current topic s%cks refuse to play that given game and post "current topic s%cks" but without mentioning the actual topic until the game is finished. Then everyone get a partial victory: the actual topic is not on discussion, so "don't discuss current topic" fundamentalists can't complain and you have expressed your opinion, preserving your right to elaborate on that later.
11 Jun 2011
*and then TELL some other one
11 Jun 2011
@kitaktus. The problem here, is that This KOTB guy, is not the first time doing this, you can check the GoE forum, and there are other threads asking to him that please do not do it again.
11 Jun 2011
@MRFvR, the thing is that, the games are chosen with voting.
and "Cigarette brands" was the democratic chosen. Is too dificult to understand?
forget my stupid maths.
11 Jun 2011
While there is voting, I see some topics that I don't recall as candidates in an election. I think Richard just inserts some topics.
11 Jun 2011
If your children decide to start smoking because they saw a game of empathy topic "cigarette brands" then odds are, u screwed up as a parent and you can't really blame littlegolem. How about instead of pretending that tobacco use doesn't exist and filtering any mention of cigarettes out of your children's lives, you talk to them about it and try to make them understand the detriments of smoking. There are far worse things to be worried about for the sake of our children then the possibility that they will see the word "cigarette" on the internet.
11 Jun 2011
And as parents, communication is still the best tool we have. Just a thought...
12 Jun 2011
@kpato: I understand your opinion and you are right.
@all:
My point of view:
I did not know anything about similar discussions in the past. I read the thread and was confuesed about the argumentation. The first thing was the "freedom of speech" argumentation -- MRFvR explained it.
The other thing:
I asked myself, how I would feel in the following szenario. Some are playing GOE and my child want to take part. I get to know the topic and ask, if this is appropriate and get these answers. Some of them are a hit in the face.
Just ask yourself: Would you suggest this topic in a game with your own children?
12 Jun 2011
Sorry, the last post was written by me. I just used the false ID.
Kitaktus
12 Jun 2011
I, for one, would.
Do you white-out the entry for "cigarette" in your home dictionary? Do you change the channel when a Nicorette commercial comes on? Do you walk half a block ahead of your children and pick up all the cigarette butts so the kids don't see them?
Parents should not, cannot, censor the world. They should inform their kids to help them (the kids) make good decisions.
12 Jun 2011
I have learned that it is common concept in american education to hide or forbid the bad things from your children. No swear words, no alcohol, no cigarettes, no drugs, no sex education. In the hope that this helps them to avoid them, but statistics show that it does no good, often the opposite is true. Where sex education is moved to college, the number of teenage pregnancies and STDs goes up, not down. Somehow, it seems, they still know how to make babies, they just don't know that babies come from that or how to avoid it. Allowing alcohol at 21 did not help either; the number of binge drinking deaths of underage college students is higher than in countries in Europe where the drinking age is 16.
I think they are loving their kids to death, trying to grow them up in a bubble of happiness and perfect live.
Unfortunately, the situation is a catch-22 - if a politician would voice that opinion or try to tell people about it, he would be ripped in pieces by the conservatives, and he would be politically dead. So there is not much hope of education about the issues, or even change...
12 Jun 2011
The drinking age is 16 in Europe? I didn't know there was a drinking age in Europe.
My wife and I were surprised to find beer offered at a McDonalds in Europe.
12 Jun 2011
@Marleys Ghost: Yes there is. Beers and wines 16. Other alcohol 18. You can buy them everywhere (some exceptions, for example in Sweden you have to buy the alcohol in special state-controlled shops) and the seller has to check the if the buyer is old enough, if they don't do so and get caught it has consequences.
12 Jun 2011
@Marleys Ghost: Yes there is. Beers and wines 16. Other alcohol 18. You can buy them everywhere (some exceptions, for example in Sweden you have to buy the alcohol in special state-controlled shops) and the seller has to check the if the buyer is old enough, if they don't do so and get caught it has consequences.
12 Jun 2011
@kitaktus re. "Is this "disrespectful" in your opinion?"
When the long-standing protocol has been not to discuss the current topic, discussing the current topic is undeniably disrespectful.
12 Jun 2011
Funny we can have a so long discussion without two clans throwing bullets at each others...
I was angry at the time the word "sexe" was banned from Empathy games answers, I will play again when it will come back. Sexe is less dangerous to mankind than tobacco! (absence of sexe would be a threat)...
Why not follow Dustin's advice and explain children that what is wrong is the abcence of respect in sexual relationships or wordings?
13 Jun 2011
I know several very clever and nice pre-teen children that know a lot about sex & drugs & alcohol, and it did not hurt them a bit. In the contrary, when the stuff starts in school, it will not be an 'interesting secret thing' for them, but they know exactly what it is and why they should be careful. However, not all parents share this thinking, and the consequences are well known. DARE is a model that tries the same approach - and quite successful - in the US, but it is not widespread.
13 Jun 2011
13 Jun 2011
I stand corrected. Should have done some research about DARE.
I still believe in the rest I said.
13 Jun 2011
Caroll, was sexe banned because it is sexual, or was it banned because it was repetitive? I think if we all started entering "wholesome" in every game, that it would be banned, too.
I hope we don't get "definite articles" as a topic, because "the" has been a banned word even longer than sexe.
13 Jun 2011
I suggested this topic. Without the meaning of promoting cigarettes. It's just a topic!
13 Jun 2011
I thought it was a good topic, it's something that can you can have a good stab at without doing any research, can easily find a whole bunch of good answers with only a little research, but still need smarts to know which brands will be known to people in various parts of the world. I passed stage 2, but fell at the 3rd hurdle, as I left some UK brands in which appear to not be well known internationally.
13 Jun 2011
@Dustin, Aganju
1) One strategy of the tobbaco industrie is to make children, teenager and even grownups believe that smoking is "normal". "You may like it or you may dislike it, but it is normal."
Playing the topc "cigaret brands" on a page like LG, especially with the "no discussion" rule absolutely fits in this strategy and I don't like to help the tobbaco industrie.
2) Your arguments are right. It is a bad idea to hide some "bad" topics and not to speak about them with our children.
But your argumentation fail since there are more alternatives than just "playing this topic in a GOE game" or "hiding this topic secret".
I want to discuss the topic "smoking" with my children in a critical manner. This is impossible in a GOE game. Here they can't learn anything about the problems caused by smoking.
LG is a internet site I find apropriate for my children if they are old enough to play the games better than randomly.
It would be a pitty if non-apropriate GOE-topics would ruin this.
@FatPhil: "... discussing the current topic is undeniably disrespectful."
3) May be. but the original post was.
kpato: "You KOTB, You were disrespectful to the democratic decision of the game.
the 50%+1 of the players, Chose that expression."
So critizing the "democratic decision" was declared as disrespectful, not discussing the current topic.
13 Jun 2011
This sounds like a job for science. I propose that all LG users who are concerned about the "cigarettes" ask their kids the following questions:
1) Have you ever smoked tobacco or wanted to try smoking prior to seeing the word "cigarette" on Little Golem?
2) Have you started or do you want to start smoking tobacco as a result of seeing the word "cigarette" on Little Golem?
If the results show any connection between GOE and smoking, I will retract everything I said.
@Kitaktus, you are undermining your own argument: "There are more alternatives than just playing this topic in a GOE game." Exactly, that is why parents should talk to their kids instead of censoring LG. You could even use this topic as a starting point for the discussion if you have not already had the conversation. If keeping your kids from smoking is the goal, the time taken to convince us would be much more productively spend trying to convince your children.
13 Jun 2011
maybe another approach would be easier to agree - thinking about cigarette brands is not something I'd like to spend my (play-)time with, so it is not a good topic?
On a different note, I used to say 'I like smokers - they make health care cheaper'. Now that is difficult to understand for US Americans, as it does probably not apply to their system. At that time, I was living in Germany, and some health care providers there actually really tried to implement a separate monthly price for health insurance for smokers and non-smokers (riding the idea that smokers would be more expensive, of course), around the late 80es. But their research found that smokers are actually cheaper for the health insurance, because they statistically die earlier (even though they produce cost in their last years, the total is smaller). Once they found out about that, and because a cheaper 'smokers' insurance would not have been politically advantageous for them (aside from - what keeps everybody from claiming to be a smoker?), they dropped the idea. We always thought this a funny idea - imagine you have to go in front of a review board and demonstrate that you are a smoker, like once a year, to get the cheaper price...
13 Jun 2011
@Dustin:
Sorry, but your questions are as meaningful as "Which bee-sting killed the bear?"
"You could even use this topic as a starting point for the discussion."
Yes you are right. And why can I do so? Because kingofthebesI started this discussion, otherwise I would not be aware of the topic.
So what is the conclusion?
These two things do not fit together. Forbidding discussions and playing topics, which need a discussion.
13 Jun 2011
if the cigarretes are bad or good, if childrens play in LG, all this topics are valides, but is NOT THE CENTRAL POINT of this thread.
im really impressed.
6 Apr 2012
thx Caroll, nice to read this one back. Now all shut up about the ongoiing game!
6 Apr 2012
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk