Learning: Yes I think that you learn more from even games, for the weaker players, while the stronger player is willing to humour them. Though handicap games do provide something interesting as well I think, usually more tactical insights than anything else. They also provide a way of understanding openings, rather than just mimicking them, I think.
Anyway, that is not the purpose of a handicap game. The main purpose is to have fun in that game. Handicap games provide a series of new puzzles for the stronger player to figure out, he may even learn from solving them. I enjoy giving handicap games, and some people enjoy taking them. Conversely, go I always find it amazing to be beaten on H5+, say, so when I get the chance I take it.
For what it's worth: I'm still keen to learn in Hex, though in go I'm definitely not! I have reached the point where I'm a strong amateur and could never be a pro. If I get better there will be even fewer people that I can have an exciting game with. As it is I've basically stopped playing altogether as I don't spend time with anyone who's a similar level anymore (in real life) Online is ok, but I've always preferred these things in real life. In Hex there were never real life opps, in go there were, and now there are not. Not sure that that's a success!
How is handicap games useful for understanding openings? Isn't it exactly the other way around? In a handicap game the first stone might be in the middle. This is contrary to a real situation Hex opening with the swap rule. In essence if you play handicap games you become better at handicap openings and handicap Hex. This is contra-productive to learning real Hex in my opinion.
Yes, I agree fully that the main purpose is to have fun with the game. But fun is not equal to winning. If it were I would understand this quest to make everybody win 50% of the times. But it isn't. If winning is what it is all about then why not just play against a crappy computer and win 100% of the games. I'm betting anyone who does that will very soon get bored. Instead I actually think that most of the fun comes from learning, one way or another. If we don't progress, we will get bored. We need new input, see new patterns, solve new problems, get new social experiences etc. The win aspect is just the goal for the game in question, not the goal for our playing the game in the first place. Am I not right?
I'm not saying that a stronger player shouldn't play against weaker players. On the contrary. But if and when you play against a less experienced player, don't cheat them of this great possibility to teach them how it is done (by totally crushing them). Don't play sub-optimal moves to "give them a chance". That way how are they supposed to know how to really play? You are teaching them BAD moves which makes you a BAD teacher. Handicap is of course better than playing bad moves, but the result is basically the same.
As the stronger player, of course, you have a valid point. It will make the game more fun and enjoyable for you. But I have yet to see a good argument why the weaker part will get any more enjoyment out of his game compared to if he instead should play a normal game against the same player. As I see it, losing is the best enticement to improve your skill and winning is a testament of your improved ability. Handicap games mess all this up, no? Just my thoughts.
Well, the opening has certain moves that people play a lot, but there are also principles. I'm pretty bad at hex openings, so I can't talk very well about them. In go, though, one needs to balance territory and influence, you need to stay away from strong stones etc. If you only play even games and always use the same patterns then you may learn moves that seem to work out without understanding why they work so well.
Playing handicap forces you to try to achieve the same goals in a new setting, like playing on an 11x13 board (something I like to do in go).
As for fun - what various players find most fun will just depend on the players, surely?
I think that handicap hex isn't a particularly good way to teach, If someone wants to learn then the best ways are probably to play even games, and to look at even games between the strongest players.
For what it's worth I think people really under-value playing lots and lots of pretty fast games. The newer you are to the game the more I think that's true.
How is handicap games useful for understanding openings? Isn't it exactly the other way around? In a handicap game the first stone might be in the middle. This is contrary to a real situation Hex opening with the swap rule. In essence if you play handicap games you become better at handicap openings and handicap Hex. This is contra-productive to learning real Hex in my opinion.
Yes, I agree fully that the main purpose is to have fun with the game. But fun is not equal to winning. If it were I would understand this quest to make everybody win 50% of the times. But it isn't. If winning is what it is all about then why not just play against a crappy computer and win 100% of the games. I'm betting anyone who does that will very soon get bored. Instead I actually think that most of the fun comes from learning, one way or another. If we don't progress, we will get bored. We need new input, see new patterns, solve new problems, get new social experiences etc. The win aspect is just the goal for the game in question, not the goal for our playing the game in the first place. Am I not right?
I'm not saying that a stronger player shouldn't play against weaker players. On the contrary. But if and when you play against a less experienced player, don't cheat them of this great possibility to teach them how it is done (by totally crushing them). Don't play sub-optimal moves to "give them a chance". That way how are they supposed to know how to really play? You are teaching them BAD moves which makes you a BAD teacher. Handicap is of course better than playing bad moves, but the result is basically the same.
As the stronger player, of course, you have a valid point. It will make the game more fun and enjoyable for you. But I have yet to see a good argument why the weaker part will get any more enjoyment out of his game compared to if he instead should play a normal game against the same player. As I see it, losing is the best enticement to improve your skill and winning is a testament of your improved ability. Handicap games mess all this up, no? Just my thoughts.
Sorry about double post. This go to browser history involuntary posting is getting annoying.. Is this site not using "POST" but "GET" for posting? I have no problems with other forums.
Jonatan, i agree with you mostly.. fun comes from learning.. and handicap games are both useful for learning and fun mostly for the stronger player.. :)
On the other hand, the weaker player gets some winning chances. This also has psychological effects. Easier to remember your win than your losses. But you can win by playing sloppy moves..
Psychological effects in good and bad. Losing a game where you had a distinct advantage does not help, does it? And is it really that satisfying winning a game where you can really never know if the win could be attributed to the extra stone and not your own ability? I don't know... all people are different.
Some comments having played some games (I am probably going on about this too much :p).
Empirically I find that under the settings I've been using the stronger player (giving the handicap) usually wins, so higher handicaps may be necessary. This has been due to mistakes of course, such as move 33 in this H2 game:
Also, regarding learning about the opening. In this game my opponent asked me whether I thought I could use my piece at A1. I suggested that (for example) as well as A1 being a ladder escape, a piece at D6 can now connect to the edge by jumping up-left where it otherwise couldn't, in the end it was clear to both of us that A1 was a big help. I think this was a good learning experience that you shows something you can't get if everyone just repeats the moves they've seen before in even games. By playing handicap (or random move opening) games you can learn more about why these moves are good. Unfortunately he resigns quite early:
I think only way is to politely ask to the author of littlegolem.. about A1, if you think about it, you see that it is quite useful exactly against center! :
I mean, in general the acute corner is quite good against center. I think this is because it doesn't require the center to be threatening. On a side note, i've been playing some Go at KGS recently and i've found it is really fun and, to use your expression, "ferociously complex"! ;)