Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

Tour de Little Golem discussion

Public forum discussion.

General

#52 · richyfourtytwo

3 Sep 2009

The result page now reflects the points won in the second Einstein group that finished recently. The page is now autogenerated (after I've copied the results manually into a textfile once. I'll probably be to lazy to automatize that as well) so I don't have to go through the hazzle of using open office base and calc any more. Player pages maybe next week.

#53 · richyfourtytwo

9 Sep 2009

Now there is a page for every player, so you can see where the points came from. I'll add pages for each stage when I find the time to do so.

Oh, and the results are corrected now. As Michael X pointed out to me some points were missing.

#55 · richyfourtytwo

9 Sep 2009

Another Einstein group has finished. Bernhard H is now in the lead.

#56 · MarleysGhost

9 Sep 2009

How many players have registered for all the stages so far?

#57 · richyfourtytwo

9 Sep 2009

I have no idea. I only put players in my list as soon as they win their first point ...

#58 · richyfourtytwo

11 Sep 2009

The 3rd Einstein group has finished in round 1. Klaashaas now has 14 points too.

#59 · richyfourtytwo

16 Sep 2009

Yet another Einstein group finished, results updated.

#60 · MarleysGhost

16 Sep 2009

To answer my own question, 20 players have signed up for all four stages whose registration has closed.

4 stages: 20 players

3 stages: 10 players

2 stages: 21 players

1 stage: 57 players

#61 · MichaeI X

17 Sep 2009

Thanks, Marley, for your efforts.

As "3 stages" shows less than 4 stages" I assume those numbers mean "exactly n stages"

and in total 108 players have at least joined one Tour tournament.

(only 55 have completed their first round currently, as one can see from Richies Standings page)

#62 · MarleysGhost

17 Sep 2009

Yes, Michael, the 209 registrations are from 108 players. "3 stages" is "exactly 3 stages".

We should have a term for players who have registered for all stages. Something other than "monster". Stage players? Complathletes? Versatiles?

#64 · richyfourtytwo

19 Sep 2009

With one Dvonn group finished we have a single leader again: Paavo Pirinen

#65 · richyfourtytwo

25 Sep 2009

The first soccer group has finished. New leader: duvelman

#66 · richyfourtytwo

27 Sep 2009

Last days for voting/registering for the next stages again!

#67 · ypercube

30 Sep 2009

Breakthrough starts tomorrow. 43 players ready to go.

StreetSoccer had 75.

EinStein had 58.

Go-9 had 38.

Dvonn had 38, too.

#68 · Thomas

1 Oct 2009

On which board size will Havannah be played?

Shouldn't there be at least two sizes, as there are also two for Reversi and Hex and three for Go?

#69 · richyfourtytwo

1 Oct 2009

A new month again. Breakthrough is running, Amazons open for registration and a new poll waits for votes.

I still think avoiding a cluster at the end would be nice, so I think we should go for go13, go19, hex13, hex19, reversi8, reversi10, connect6, gomoku, GWG or WYPS next. (I think connect6 and gomoku and equally wyps and GWG are similar enough to avoid having those in sequence too.)

#70 · richyfourtytwo

1 Oct 2009

@Thomas: To avoid such discussions I made a simple rule: 'Each game for which you can separately register in a championship counts as one game type, so we'll have 3 Go game types, but just one Dots and Boxes for example.'

Size 10 seems to be what the Havannah championship is using, so we'll use that too.

I hope Richard will not change the structure of the site radically. If he suddenly decided to have championships for all different variants my simple rule would break down and we'd have to reconsider.

#71 · Hjallti

1 Oct 2009

I hope that WYPS will be played with numbers not with words. Both arithmic series as the ascending variant might be played as one is fast win version and the other full board.

#72 · Dvd Avins

2 Oct 2009

Declaration of intent: To vote for Go19 not in this poll, but in the next one.

The championship started in September. If there were support to start the Tour segment on November 1, I wouldn't mind, but I can see if some think it's too close. But we need to start it soon, because it takes so long. I think it should be a priority to start longer games early and have the last few games be short, so we can approximate one full isolated cycle.

#73 · Hjallti

19 Oct 2009

bump

I want to have this on the first page :-)

#74 · richyfourtytwo

28 Oct 2009

Being back from holiday I finally found the time to update the results. 4 groups have finished in the meantime. This didn't change the leader though, it's still duvelman.

Oh, and btw: If you want to register for round 6 (Amazons) or vote for round 7, now would be a good time.

#75 · richyfourtytwo

28 Oct 2009

To ensure a more or less uniform distribution of similar games over the stages I may start reducing the choices in the polls soon. Here are 3 rules I'll apply:

1. One of the 3 go variants shall be played in each third of the stages. (one in stage 1-7, one in stage 8-15, one in stage 16-22)

2. One of the 2 variants of reversi as well as hex shall be played in each half of the stages (1-11, 12-22)

3. Between 2 similar games at least 2 other stages have to be played. Different variants of one game count as similar (go9, go13 etc.), connect6 and gomoku are considered similar too, as well as WYPS and GwG.

#76 · Hjallti

28 Oct 2009

Small question: you might use rule 2 as well to all similar games as explained in 3 or is this not longer possible due to what we already have done. Note that your rule implies that go can't be voted as the game of round 7.

#77 · Hjallti

28 Oct 2009

If you apply similar to rule 2 the choices for the round 8 games are really reduced to: rev10, rev, hex19, hex, gomoku, connect6, Wyps and GwG. Since 4 of these games have to be in the first 11 stages, and there are only 4 stages left.

Then if in 12, 13 and 14 no go variant is chosen, the poll of 15 is between go19 and go13.

#78 · richyfourtytwo

29 Oct 2009

These rules were not meant to be applied to the current poll. I will apply them to determine which games I'll offer in future polls. I have considered handling similar games in the same way, as you suggest. The immediate restrictions for round 8 were one reason not to do that on such short notice. Although, if there is a general consensus I should do as you propose, I will. (Well, if there were such a consensus it should show in the voting results anyway, making all this redundant!)

#79 · Bernhard Herwig

29 Oct 2009

Somehow I always supposed the games come in the same order for ever. So, after all games have been played once, it starts again with Go9, Einstein, Dvonn, Streetsoccer, Breakthrough,.... As soon as the second Go9 tournament has ended, all the Go9 points awarded at the first Go9 tournament are deleted and replaced by the new Go9 points. So that this is all kind of circular. It doesnt matter when you join in, 22 tournaments later, you will have played everything once.

Of course a new game added to the server might be added later to the circle of games.

Did I misunderstand?

#81 · Dvd Avins

29 Oct 2009

Me, too, except new games would be interspersed.

#82 · Marius Halsor

30 Oct 2009

I had that impression too. Oh, and I don't see the need for these new rules. If people really want that, the polls should show it. If people think it's fine that they start GO13 and GO19 as the two last games, then why not?

#83 · Ricardo (Santos)

30 Oct 2009

Agree, I thought so too. When all games have been played once, it should start over with Go9. If let's say Go19 be the first game it will probably not be possible to erase the old result. However, of course, if Einstein or Dvonn is chosen it might still be possible... How is it going to be?

#84 · mungo

30 Oct 2009

I didn't. But when I read the information again your interpretation seems correct. The drawback, in my opinion, is that there will never be a Tour winner, only a Tour leader. And leadership will be very dependent on how many tournaments you have finished, so if you happen to have slow players in your latest tournaments it will be harder to take the lead.

I like the idea of having a declared Tour winner when the first full cycle is completed.

#85 · richyfourtytwo

30 Oct 2009

Yes, of course it'll start over again, at least that was my impression too! ;-)

I can see now though, that what I wrote about the order of stages can be read in a way that contradicts this. But all I wrote above about stage order was meant for the first 22 stages only. In other words: for the first cycle. From the second cycle on there is no more need for polls. Unless 2 or more new games are added simultaneously that is.

@Marius:

> If people really want that, the polls should show it.

I thought so too at first. But I now have the impression that quite a lot of players just vote for their favourite game, enter that one tournament and don't really care for the tour as a whole. And, to make that perfectly clear: there is nothing wrong with that. But I assume players who want to play (almost) all stages prefer not to have clusters of similar games and these are the people the tour is primarily meant for (although, to repeat myself, everyone is invited to play as few stage as one likes). My assumptions may be wrong of course. So if a couple of players who entered at least 4 of the 6 stages so far tell me so here in this thread or in a private message I will certainly drop those rules. Of course, if you actually see some sense in those rules you are allowed to voice that opimion too. :-)

About cycle winners: Surele we should declare such. Especially as there is no guarantee that he/she will ever be a tour leader. Theoretically stage 1 of cycle 2 may finish before the last stage of cycle 1 and that would mean stage 1 cycle 1 points wouldn't be valid any more at the moment the last points in cycle 1 are assigned.

When we come closer to this we can discuss what kind of stats we want to keep from earlier cycles. But there is no rush yet, I'd say.

#86 · FatPhil

30 Oct 2009

We have enough things that have winners already - I like the idea of there only ever being a leader in the tour.

#87 · Dvd Avins

30 Oct 2009

I have entered every stage so far, and I intend to enter every stage for at least the first cycle.

I support the new rules.

I very much want to see a leaderboard that encompasses all of the first cycle and nothing else.

#88 · Hjallti

31 Oct 2009

The circular part is just the reason that these rules are necessary:

if it was once it wouldn't matter.

The pol system might inply that rev and rev10 are the last two (least popular) and than hex as penultimate and so on...

I would think that the voters would intelligent and vote some of these games earlier to avoid this stacking up, but that doesn't happen. So Richy is wise to impose it.

Say in three years we are in the cycle and we come into the months corresponding with the last chosen game. Suppose Go19 and Go13 than the 3 go games are next to eachother and before maybe the two reversi games.

The reason we need these rules here is the same is we need all the laws... it organises things better if people make choices only to benefit themselfs. Strange but not unexpected this happens on a site with only people who consider themselfs to be intelligent....

#89 · richyfourtytwo

1 Nov 2009

Another Soccer group had finished. The website should now be up to date again.

#90 · Bernhard Herwig

2 Nov 2009

My opinion about clusters of similar games: Its nice to avoid them, but it is not really important. If there are clusters, that is no big deal. If Richy wants to avoid them (rsp. if people dont want them): Richy should start the remaining polls as he thinks it is best. Be aware: If you really want to avoid clusters you might have to restrict at some point the choices e.g. just to the two Reversi variants.

#91 · ypercube

7 Nov 2009

Last EinStein group of round 1 finished (more points for duvelman!).

Round 2 groups have started.

#92 · richyfourtytwo

8 Nov 2009

Yes, duvelman has a claer lead now. Website is updated.

#94 · richyfourtytwo

11 Nov 2009

A couple of groups have finished, the go9 final being one of them. Congrats to Bernhard Herwig, klaashaas and Johubber. klaashas and duvelman are now sharing the lead with 26 points.

#95 · Hjallti

11 Nov 2009

In the second round of EinStein those leaders had a direct battle with duvelman as winner!

I hope he has his where-abouts filled in right because the Flemish Anti-Doping Tribunal is on his toes already... :-)

#96 · richyfourtytwo

25 Nov 2009

Several more groups have finished. There was quite a bit of movement in the rankings. Our now unique leader is Klaashaas 5 points ahead of Bernhard H.

And btw: just a couple of days left for registering for dots and boxes or voting for stage 8.

#97 · ypercube

25 Nov 2009

Will you add the Toroidal Go version in the Tour?

#98 · richyfourtytwo

27 Nov 2009

As soon as there is a specific Torodial Go championship. Which might happen soon or never. Who knows. :-)

#99 · richyfourtytwo

2 Dec 2009

I've updated the website again. 3 more groups had finished. Now Bernhard Herwig is in the lead followed by klaashaas with just 1 point difference.

#100 · ypercube

2 Dec 2009

The little monsters are rising :)

Last page