#51 · Ray Garrison
31 Aug 2009
maybe someone should sent Richard M a message about this, he may not know about the problem. He made his moves earlier today against me and replied to a message I sent him.
Public forum discussion.
31 Aug 2009
maybe someone should sent Richard M a message about this, he may not know about the problem. He made his moves earlier today against me and replied to a message I sent him.
1 Sep 2009
Perhaps Richard knows about it.
He may have left in on puupose this way for a few days. So, people who could not log (in the 3-4 days that Golem was out of connection with the rest of the world) to play in their games without losing from time.
2 Sep 2009
Ok Pedantic, fine. I am still winning at -112 hours approximatly 1 hour ahead of klaashass if I did the math right.
Yes, perhaps Richard knows and wishes to use this as a mechanism to deal with down time. I am just happy he keeps the site going at all.
But most importantly, I am still winning.
2 Sep 2009
Hey, you can't claim your win so easily! I'm at -118 hours now, and your forum post says '5 hours ago'.
How can we find out who's winning?
2 Sep 2009
You just both post the game ids of the games you're talking about, rather than bragging about times without any evidence :-)
2 Sep 2009
Well, I did say IF I did the math right. I never claimed that I actually did it right.
How's this: At 12:36 Greenwich Mean Time (standard)I had a game at -123 hours.
here is a site for GMT- http://wwp.greenwichmeantime.com/
AND I posted last so...WOOOOO HOOOOO!
2 Sep 2009
That's still no evidence. Just post a link to the game.
2 Sep 2009
evidence-shmevidence
I win, "Mission Accomplished" and all of that. That is how it works right? Just put on a flight suit and declare victory. Well I'm wearing my flight suit and saying Wooooo Hoooooo! (and ignoring the fact that I have no idea what is going on) Whoops, did I just drift into a critique of my former commander and chief?
2 Sep 2009
12.51 GMT: -124 hours
How does a link to the game gives us enough evidence, wccanard?
2 Sep 2009
Well, that way we can have two windows open at the same time. If, whenever we refresh both windows, one of the games have one more hour negative time than the other, we'll know who wins. Unless there are other, hitherto unknown participants in this rather awkward contest :-)
2 Sep 2009
12:55 and mine just rolled to 124 as well. We would actually have to figure out when the game hour clock rolls over for each. That sounds like too much work for a joke. Rats, I might not be winning. I may have to suspend some laws and start torturing people.
2 Sep 2009
Fine, here is the game for which I say "Mission Accomplished"
2 Sep 2009
Mostly I am just posting a lot so that Richard notices and does something about the negative time. Perhaps I should just send him a note.
2 Sep 2009
Yes, I don't object to random rubbish like this keeping the thread at the top of the forum postings file. When the daemon restarts we all shut up, right?
@klaashaas: are you going to tell us which of your 100+ games is the one that you're claiming beats elroy?
2 Sep 2009
The clock moved from -124 to -125 somewhere between 1:46:06 p.m. (GMT + 0:00) and 1:48:07 p.m. (GMT + 0:00)
It's a close battle!
2 Sep 2009
OH NOOOOO! My opponent Timed out and I won. I have lost the WHO HAS AN OPPONENT WITH THE MOST NEGATIVE HOURS IN A GAME competition.
...Thank you Richard
2 Sep 2009
Besides saying "thank you" to Richard, I think regular players, or at least heavy users of this LG site, should join as a member and pay annual membership fees. This really can help Richard continuously maintain/improve this wonderful site which most of us enjoy so much, right?
2 Sep 2009
@euhuang: here's another way of looking at it. If I could see a stable site which didn't keep breaking, I might be more inclined to pay. Having said that, if 50 percent of heavy users here think "I'll pay to make it better" and the other 50 percent think "I'll pay when it's better", then eventually most people will pay.
Having said *that*, I note that on sites like jijbent.nl (where many people pay, and people are employed with the money to work on making sure the site is up, the daemons are running and no-one is cheating, so things get fixed much more quickly) the admins made it work by crippling the site for non-payers. Richard currently offers very little to those who pay and perhaps this was an incorrect business decision on his part.
Back on topic: is the daemon running? Certainly some tournaments just started, so it was running at some point very recently---but looking at the main tournaments page I still see some monthly cups with 5,6,7 people registered, which makes me think that the daemon started and then stopped again very quickly.
2 Sep 2009
The game of empathy is at -112 hours, but my absentee opponents have lost vacation days.
2 Sep 2009
To reply to euhuang: In fact I said thank you to Richard AND I am a member. I assume people will become members when they figure out that money is, unfortunately, what makes the world go 'round and sooner or later it will be what makes this site continue on, become something entirely different or just dissolve into mere electrons someday. For now it is a quirky, wonderful place on the web that some guy whom I have never met named Richard makes happen. Scolding people for not being members will not help and I like the site just how it is anyway.
To wccanard: Chicken or the egg you take your pick.
It is strange what just happened if not every issue was resolved. All I know is that Richard has chosen to smile on me and deliver me from my plight. I would like to think he delivered me because I spoke in his language by making a game out of it. Perhaps that is the best way to pray to Richard. All hail Richard who works in mysterious ways.
2 Sep 2009
I'm also still waiting for the Tour de Little Golem StreetSoccer user tournament to start. It indeed looks like there still is a problem.
About membership: Not crippling the site for non-members might be an incorrect business decision, but that doesn't make it a bad decision. Because of the low entry barrier we have lots of (also lots of good) players here. Of course LittleGolem isn't perfect. LittleGolem as an open source project run by a group of people and thus being more responsive, that would sound perfect, for me at least. But as it is it is more than good enough to be supported by me. Probably Richard would get twice as much money if people were not so lazy. It took me about a year to get from 'I really should become a member' to actually doing it (which took about 10 minutes).
2 Sep 2009
There is clearly still a problem: look at the main tournaments page to see that there are plenty of monthly cups with more than 4 people registered. My guess is that Richard just started lots of tournaments by perhaps running some sort of sub-process that started monthly cups going, but didn't trigger GoE or user tourneys?
Another gripe I've always had about this place is that Richard never tells you what is happening. Why don't we get an explanation here, **even one of the form "I'm very busy, I'll get round to things in a few days, hopefully Friday"** or something like that---that would be much better than just leaving us all to stew. He must have spent quite a long time (several hours, at the very least) programming when creating the blog that appeared a few months ago on this site, but now never posts to it (and updates on what's happening would take several minutes, at the very most).
3 Sep 2009
It wasn't just a starting of a lot of tournaments that occurred was it? My game with all of the negative hours did just finally time out and so did my opponent's other games in the Twixt championship we were playing in. All the evidence I have is that he fixed just my opponent's negative time issue though that seems absurd from a programming standpoint. (Who knows, maybe my attempt to gripe in what I considered a humorous way got his attention and he really did smile just on me.) Did the process get fixed for a short time or did it just get fixed for some games... who knows. I guess a little more information would be nice but I personally am going to cut the guy some slack, this site is run by his good will basically. Really, how many members are there. Not many that I see. I am just happy I have somewhere to play Twixt.
18 Sep 2009
18 Sep 2009
-2 for a game of mine now :(
18 Sep 2009
Aww crap. I am desperate for a game I'm playing to finish and now this. And there's evidence to suggest that when Richard fixes the problem, he might donate some vacation days to the "victims"...
18 Sep 2009
So you should use them ;-) go and get yourself some vacations!
When you come back, many people will have played and some new tournaments will have started...
18 Sep 2009
Oh---I go on vacation! I just play by sniffing wireless connections etc ;-) In fact I was in France a month or so ago with the kids.
20 Sep 2009
reluctant bump
20 Sep 2009
Games where it is your opponent's turn
Game Time Opponent Rating Tournament Moves
#1081307 -53 hours Ronek info 1484 Havannah - rated game 11
#1082031 -52 hours Ronek info 1484 Havannah - rated game 5
#1074739 -11 hours Bernhard Herwig info 1594 havannah.ch.2.2.2 64
#1091110 0 hours Lukasz Lew info 1947 havannah.mc.2009.sep.1.7 13
20 Sep 2009
Yes, we all know. This is quite a common occurrence at the minute I'm afraid. One of the disadvantages of the vacation system here is that some games drag on and on for months (which in some cases means some championships drag on and on for months). These no-time-out issues, sadly, make things even worse. And when Richard secretly refunds vacation days this makes them even worse still.
21 Sep 2009
I am just wondering if it would technically possible (and advisable) to have somewhere in cyberspace (unrelated to the LittleGolem server) some bot(s), that checks at some crucial times (for instance 1:00 CET) if the time of empathy or some games is negative. (That this is possible is a positive of course). and then would be able, if the times are negative, to send some message (a 'kick') to the update bots of richards so that if there is only some minor error they wake up again?
21 Sep 2009
I think the general conjecture is that, when the daemon stops,
(a) Richard knows there's a problem
(b) it takes more than 20 seconds to sort out
(c) hence it doesn't get sorted out for a while.
I am guessing that prodding a bot won't solve this.
I think it's a shame that Richard doesn't explain some more of the details of why it happens and how much work it is to get things restarted when they stop. This makes people have to resort to guesswork. What is so daft is that Richard has got such a big user base including plenty of "geeks" who would, I'm sure, happily contribute to the upkeep of the site by doing what is required to restart the daemon, had they got access to the innards of the site. I think that, given the current state of the site (very popular, daemon broken about 1 day in 7 on average over the last couple of months) he would benefit a great deal from nominating an "inner circle" of people who were prepared to do some work/admin for him for free. I see that game 1081307 is currently on -71 hours so that's 3 days that we have "lost" so far in this outage, and we lost five more earlier this month (see above). Maybe Richard is busy, but there are certainly people out there who aren't, and who would be happy to help.
21 Sep 2009
Or redesign it. If a daemon that's supposed to be running all the time abends, and the cause of the abend has to be analyzed before restarting will do any good, then replacing the daemon with a cron job or scheduled task that runs 2 or 3 times an hour, ends as soon as it's done, and, to reduce the effect of some task that it's abending on, randomizes the order in which it tackles its various tasks would at least allow a lot of the site to proceed, albeit with the abending task still left undone until it can be manually analyzed.
Another thing I've wondered is whether a daemon is needed at all. Could the code that displays the Game of Empathy page or a player's list of games notice that it's displaying a negative time and just do what needs to be done itself?
21 Sep 2009
Daemon restarted!
Thanks Richard.
21 Sep 2009
Hey...hang on. I think what has happened is similar to what happened on the 2nd of Sept. Lots of tournaments started 3 minutes ago (as I type), but GoE is still in negative time. So I conjecture (based on what happened back then) that
(i) vacation days got used by negative-timers
(ii) everyone is in positive time again
(iii) user tournaments that were due to start did _not_ start
(iv) monthly cups that were due to start _did_ start
(v) GoE did _not_ start.
21 Sep 2009
Even though vacation days got used, game 1069910 still did not finish!
Check out the amazing
http://www.littlegolem.net/jsp/game/game.jsp?gid=1069910
yeradigo did not move now for *60 days* [it was his move on 23 July and I am writing this message on 21 September, 60 days later] and still he/she did not time out.
21 Sep 2009
I have three games with yeradigo as well, all of which have not had a move in 60 days like yours
21 Sep 2009
GoE is back up and running so we're probably all back to normal. Hooray! M. Seymour---it's not my game, it's just a game, but this is just a pedantic point.
21 Sep 2009
yeradigo joined littlegolem on July 23 and is not a member. he/she has won 3 games all by time. he/she made no more than one move in some of his/her games (on July 23)
He/she is still showing on vacation as of today. More than likely will forfeit all games soon, so watching this player should be able to determine exactly how many vacation days were added due to the August down times.
21 Sep 2009
yeradido has 102 games in progress
22 Sep 2009
Yeradigo's games have started to end.
22 Sep 2009
so it looks like 61 days of inactivity for Yeradigo. (thanks wccanard for calculating this and sending me a message). So what does this mean? 240 hours is 10 days which is when his vacation should have kicked in, and 20 days of vacation gives him 30 days before he should have timed out of his games. I know Richard added a few days (I got somewhere between 3 and 5 extra days of vacation added back due to the outage in August). I wonder why it took 61 days for him to time out? surely he did not have 51 days of vacation, did he? Perhaps his negative hours were not converted into vacation days? any ideas?
22 Sep 2009
I think any negative hours are converted to 24 positive hours, at the expense of one vacation day. Also, though until a few years ago timeouts and vacation days happened as soon as "1 hour" was gone, now each day has either approximately or exactly 25 hours when vacation is being charged. Kind of days in the Jewish calendar, which overlap because they begin at sundown and end the next day at dark.
23 Sep 2009
At some point yeradigo will have been on things like -100 hours, when the daemon was down for 4-5 days, which happened recently, and then he loses 0 vacation days, and when the daemon restarts he only loses one. And then he gets bonus days for some undisclosed reason from Richard. And the days the site was down don't count either (I think there were about 2 of these in the last 2 months). This is all clutching at straws however, because it never gets anywhere near to 60. This was the reason I brought up the topic on another thread. I'm reluctant to bump this thread with this discussion; I tend to only bump it when the daemon is down.
24 Sep 2009
I have got an explanation for the 61 days: all vacation days between the 22nd of july and the 22nd of august got deleted. (The dates could easily be a few days of.)
As Yeradigo took 20 days of vacation during that time he got 20 days back on his account. I took nearly 10 days of vacation then, and got nearly ten days back. Maybe Ray could confirm that he took about 4 days of vacation in that period, which are not longer on his list.
24 Sep 2009
I think that the correct explanation is a combination of the above three comments.
I was really on vacation from Aug. 14 through Aug 22. My vacation time probably kicked on on Aug 16 or so. When I got back on Aug 22 I was encountering problems with little golem but I was showing vacation days as expected, then Richard gave back all the vacation days that I incurred on my actual week long vaction, and then I immediately lost another vacation day (Aug 23) due to time pressure and little golem downages. I also currently show a vacation day that I incurred on July 31. So Perhaps Richard returned all vacation days from Aug.1 through Aug 21 or Aug 22? So let's say he returned 21 vacation days. So yeradigo had 41 vacation days plus his original 240 hours for a total of 51 days. That leaves 10 days unaccounted for, and these additional 10 days can be explained by Dvd Avins and wccanards explanation of many negative hours being convereted into positive 24 hours at the expense of only one vacation day.
We will never know exactly how many vacation days were added unless Richard tells us, but the good thing is that things are running smooth (for now)
25 Sep 2009
I spoke too soon...things are not so smooth! I have an opponent at -6 hours :(
27 Sep 2009
bump
30 Sep 2009
Game Time Opponent Rating Tournament Moves
#1082031 0 hours Ronek info 1484 Havannah - rated game 5
#1081307 1 hours Ronek info 1484 Havannah - rated game 11
Ronek has now twice hit -75, yoyoing between 24 and 0 a couple of times in between and indeed afterwards.
I wonder how often he will yoyo now before he hits the next -75?
Can he reach -100?
Thrillsville!