Public forum discussion.
8 Feb 2009
I don't think that parity of vacant positions on an initial board has got much relevance in ataxx. Someone always ends up jumping after the opening few moves and then the parity has gone.
I once wrote a computer program to play ataxx and it found all sorts of weird lines. The endgame is where all the fireworks are---I was surprised. You think you're drifting into a stable position and then the computer starts jumping around, making holes in funny places. I've seen games go on for a very long time (50 moves or so) when the computer played itself, when there were only two vacant squares for the entire line! Based on this I can't believe that parity at the beginning is important. I think ataxx is one of those chaotic games where computers will probably play much better than humans because humans will find it so hard to analyse many moves ahead. That's my guess anyway.
8 Feb 2009
I've played a lot of Ataxx at Vying Games (7x7, random blocks). I'm only an okay player, but I don't think there's a noticeable advantage for the first player. The blocks certainly effect tactical play, and the endgame, but they don't seem to have any effect on the opening.
Pretty much everyone opens by splitting on the diagonals towards the center. This is what the board often looks like after a few moves:
<br/>o.....x
<br/>.o...x.
<br/>..o....
<br/>.......
<br/>.......
<br/>.x.....
<br/>x.....o
<br/>
Basically, the general rule is:
1) Split toward the center. Blocks change the route but not the intent.
2) Avoid getting within range to be attacked with a split (if you're going to get attacked you at least want your opponent to jump)
Since the blocks are random but fair (rotational symmetry), I really don't know how I'd bid. The openings in Ataxx are actually so routine as to be boring.
Like, wcc says, parity changes so often throughout the game that it doesn't seem worth looking at until the board starts to fill in. Then it's important to look at parity around the corners or other groups of empty cells, of course.
Interestingly enough, in Hexxagon it seems to be better to open along the outer edges, *not* towards the center as I've just described for Ataxx...
9 Feb 2009
pincers
a game on a standard chess or checkerboard, or any suitable gridded board
pieces of two colours, one for each player, may be put by players on any open square. when a player places a piece so that it 'pinches' her opponents piece diagonally between two stones of the player's colour - like a jump in checkers - the player gets an extra turn, placing a stone anywhere, and if it 'pinches' again, she earns another turn. if a piece pinches two single pieces at once, two extra turns are earned, etc. the game continues until the board is filled, the player with most pieces of her colour wins.
example of a 'pinch'
<br/>---x
<br/>--o-
<br/>-X--
<br/>
multiple 'pinch'
<br/>x---x
<br/>-o-o-
<br/>--x--
<br/>
pinching is optional
9 Feb 2009
*important note
unlike a jumped checker, a pinched piece remains on the board. it may even be pinched again from a different diagonal, if available.
9 Feb 2009
pah tum is a very interesting game,
and not played on so many sites
9 Feb 2009
IMHO, LG shouldn't try to implement every game with a hint of merit (tens of thousands of games). That approach would clutter the small list of high quality games already offered. There are tonnes of sites offering every bizarre chess, Go and backgammon variant under the son. Rather LG should take, in my opinion, a more measured approach and slowly build up a core of classic and modern classic games. Modern classics, like LOA and Amazons are excellent additions which will generally stand out from the crowd due to recommendations and/or growing numbers of players. While it might be controversial, perhaps over time the odd game here or there might be retired.
With that in mind, and echoing the suggestion of many others, I'd say that top priority be to offer the most played boardgame of all, Chinese Chess or Xiangqi.
9 Feb 2009
I completely second alain's comment (even though I'd want Shogi before Xiangqi, but would be happy with any of the two).
10 Feb 2009
I'd be happy to comment later, but for the moment I'm the second to second Alain's comment.
I have tried to interest players in the one pure implementation of the column checkers mechanism deployed in Bashne and Lasca. I had hoped players would be interested in a game that is quintessential in the same sense as Checkers, Hex and Go: pondering the mechanism, and listening carefully they unfold their rules without 'human interference'.
Such games, whether modest and deep as Checkers and Hex, or wide and deep as Go, deserve attention because they reward with beauty those who are prepared to invest the time and energy to understand their intricacies.
I'm a games inventor, so I would appear biased by definition.
I'm not.
You can trust Emergo to provide more beauty than you ever expected.
12 Feb 2009
Chameleon would be fun and no trouble at all to implement here as the GUI is the same as hex.
I'd like to see how best hex players would invent strategies for it and if a color gets played more than the other one.
12 Feb 2009
carroll, you can invite me to a game in pbem. i am gmorales there, i think :)
19 Feb 2009
21 Feb 2009
I'd like to see games dissimilar to what we currently have.
I think Phutball would fit the bill.
21 Feb 2009
Umm, how do you play Conway's Game of life with other people?
21 Feb 2009
Pure abstract games i'd like to see:
Phutball, yes!
Trax, yes!
Shogi, yes!
XiangQi, yes!
Ordo, yes!
Games with chance:
Dice Hex, yes!
Games with secret information:
Stratego, yes!
Games with more than two players, or combination of the above:
Rock, Paper, Scissors, yes!
Bridge, yes!
21 Feb 2009
@David Milne: How about this?
The rectangular board is divided into three regions. Player one sets up the initial state of one region, alpha. Player two sets up the initial state of another region, beta. The third region, which I presume would be between alpha and beta, is initially blank.
After that initial setup, the board progresses from state to state according to the rules of the Game of Lime. The first state in which two predetermined cells, A and B, in the third region are different determines the winner. If A=On B=Off, player one wins. A=Off B=On is a win for player two. If A and B are either both off or both on for the first N states, the game is a draw.
The size of the board and the value of N determines how much computer power may be required to determine the outcome. We don't want to overload the server.
You could have each player initialize his or her region without knowledge of the other, although that makes for a game that can hardly be said to be "turn based", or you could have the players take turns determining one cell at a time.
21 Feb 2009
I'm sure you already know you can play Phutball at Vying Games, ypercube.... but, for those who don't know: Phutball at Vying Games. Phutball is one of my favorite games, I'm always looking for opponents. I'm 'eki' there, I have a few tables open or send me an invite if you'd like to play. There's also a couple open spots for the tourney that's about to start.
21 Feb 2009
I'm looking forward to Marley's explanation of what the "Game of Lime" is ;-) Does it involve gin?
Isn't the optimal strategy just going to be to fire a glider at the square you want to light up? Or, space permitting, make the fastest known glider gun?
Yeah, but it's not turn-based at all, and turn-based is the strength of this server.
22 Feb 2009
Well the first, building phase is turnbased. But after that it is automatic without further intervention. If A and B are equidistant then you can decide which to first shoot at. If you both shoot at different ones you may get a draw.
A possible variant is after the set up phase, each player may change the state of one cell in his area. Either simultaneous display. or alternating between the players, which one will play first to be followed by the other.
22 Feb 2009
I meant change the status of one cell in your area for each life generation in the second phase of the game.
22 Feb 2009
what about a non-competitive game of life "graffiti wall" which anyone could add to, so long as each "post" consisted of ten [or any arbitrary but limited number number of] changes to existing cells. as in a forum, post credit and date would be shown in a pop-up or something. then you could show 10 [or a similarly arbitrary but limited number of] generations for each addition, by hitting refresh. game of life enthusiasts could however download a complete text file "movie" [with the complete history of the wall, or say from spring to fall 2009] to run on their own computer, much the way pgn and sgf files are already. if tournament-like "seasons" were used, "arbitrary but limited numbers" could be tweaked or varied.
22 Feb 2009
Game of Lime? I did write that, didn't I? I must have meant the Gaffe of Life.
I agree it needs something more strategically interesting than just building the fastest glider. We'd want A closer to beta and B closer to alpha, so just sending a glider to the nearest target does not win, and defense is important.
I like the idea that both players get to change a single cell per generation. Is requiring the cell you change to be in your own region sufficient? Or must the rules allow it to be elsewhere?
22 Feb 2009
Perhaps there could be a quarantine area enclosing the two goal cells where you could not change the status of a cell, but you could intervene any where else, including in the opponent's area in the second phase.
22 Feb 2009
if the two "goal cells" were "on", you could intervene directly, but if either was "off" you could not. then one strategy might be finding an indirect way, sach as with a glider, to turn them "on"
22 Feb 2009
in which case, it only makes sense to use the "swap" rule.
26 Feb 2009
Trax would fit LG style :) i like it!!
26 Feb 2009
And would improve greatly my chances for the Monstership :)
26 Feb 2009
I love Trax and it is one of these games you can't play home because nobody will take the trouble to learn it and being beaten each time for some weeks...
26 Feb 2009
Trax is great, but wouldn't there be a copyright infringement? I think LG would have to apply for permission first. Not that I would refuse when I were the manufacturer.
26 Feb 2009
Is there a licensing issue implementing Trax, since it is a proprietary game?
26 Feb 2009
ypercube: And would improve greatly my chances for the Monstership :)
So I see. And now I know your real name, too. It looks like you may be the 2nd best player in the world.
26 Feb 2009
There goes my coverage...
27 Feb 2009
I think goldtoken has trax so there might be no problem with the copyright.
27 Feb 2009
They start with this note:
"As 8x8 Trax is a proprietary game, these rules are the intellectual property of David Smith. They have been reproduced here with permission."
So if you mean by 'no problem' that permission is likely to be granted, I agree.
27 Feb 2009
Yes, I just thought if Goldtoken managed, than little golem could manage as well...
28 Feb 2009
I feel sure that David Smith would be delighted to grant permission for LG to host Trax. I think that the challenger in the last World Trax Championship, who is a member of the LG community of players would let David Smith know that LG is the place where the strategies and tactics of Trax would be placed under an intense scrutiny by the resident LG community of players.
I am sure that Christian Freeling is quite happy that Havannah has found its way onto LG.
28 Feb 2009
@ David
That was a good guess ;-)
28 Feb 2009
I would ask David Smith what he thinks about it if Richard shows interest, I feel pretty sure he would be very happy.
I'm not sure though that he would be very pleased with the swap rule (not that there is any indication it is needed ;-)
28 Feb 2009
You mean swapping the black tiles back to the red tiles :-)
28 Feb 2009
@ David
That was a good guess ;-)