#152 · Art Duval
12 Jun 2013
Marius' observation suggests the possibility that "E" stands for "Equation".
Public forum discussion.
12 Jun 2013
Marius' observation suggests the possibility that "E" stands for "Equation".
12 Jun 2013
1+1=10.
12 Jun 2013
I made a mistake in an earlier post: "P" stands for "Posts", not points. But "points" is a contribution to the virtual final standings.
12 Jun 2013
The quikc brown fox jumps over the lazy dog.
12 Jun 2013
Writing nonsense or copying previous posts earns you negative points. This is scored in another category than "consecutive".
12 Jun 2013
Whoever scores the most points will win. Does that count as a rule?
12 Jun 2013
There are five categories of "scoring". The two first are explained. BEFORE Carrolls post, which Hjallti said was the first to score in a specific category, people had already made posts with three positive scores. However, there were also posts with two negative scores (and one positive, obviously). Since we only were scoring in four categories up until that point, according to Hjallti, one of the categories must be such that it is possible to get both positive and negative scores. This is probably the category where "nonsense" and copied posts go. But how do one get a positive score in that category?
12 Jun 2013
"L" is worth 15 points, and can only be awarded to one player.
12 Jun 2013
The L bonus is awarded to the second player to mention it
12 Jun 2013
In the PCGSE scoring, G means "game" and is related to identifying the rules and outcome of the game, and S means "spelling" and is somehow related to spelling correctly and not copying previous posts. I am unsure how a post qualifies for a positive score in the S category, but it's possible.
12 Jun 2013
Not all rules are fixed before the end of the game.
12 Jun 2013
I think points are awarded for giving external references. Here is a list of other games with secret rules. I guess we all are familiar with "Calvinball"...
12 Jun 2013
Mao is the only one of these I'm familiar with. I know people who love it, though I'm not particularly keen on it myself.
12 Jun 2013
Little Golem is full of these fun "Forum Games". Some time ago, there were several fun posts with riddles and puzzles. I wonder if I'd be able to find the again if I searched...
12 Jun 2013
It's one of the things I love about the site
12 Jun 2013
@Martyn: Having a lot of nerds here, playing nerdy games?
Talking about the game as the game reminds me that I always feel uncomfortable with the kind of proofs from computer science that mixes levels:
- Halting problem: You cannot decide whether or not a Turing machine will eventually stop for a certain input. The proof enumerates all Turing machines and their inputs and gives a particular universal machine its own number as input, which mixes levels.
- Gödel's incompleteness theorem: Given a sufficient complex consistent logical system (supports exponentation) there are true propositions that cannot be proved. The proof again enumerates all possible propositions, constructs the proposition: P="The proposition X has no proof." and manages to replace X by the number of P itself, which mixes levels.
- Cantor's diagonal method to prove that there are more real numbers than natural numbers first contructs an infinite table and then misses a table entry that is constructed from a certain walk through the table itself, which mixes levels.
This is all like Baron Munchhausen, who pulls itself on his own hair out of the mud.
12 Jun 2013
@Mirko ...there are true propositions that cannot be proved.
Is this something fundamentally different from Euclid's last axiom? Either postulate
"There is exactly one line parallel to a given line through a given point not on the given line" (which holds in flat two- or three-dimensional space) or
"There is no line parallel to a given line through a given point not on the given line" (which holds on the surface of a sphere)
gives a realizable geometry. If given all but the last of Euclid's axioms, is a version of the parallel postulate an example of what Goedel meant by "true but not provable"?
Not that this has anything to do with Hjallti's baffling game.
12 Jun 2013
If (good) equations earn points, they won't be granted if the post was copied from elsewhere.
12 Jun 2013
Marley, this is not the same. Replacing a postulate by another one or adding a new postulate gives you a new logic system. (BTW, typically, the set of postulates is infinite, since there are variables involved. In fact, each postulate that contains variables is a scheme for postulates.) For Euclid the postulate about parallel lines is independent from the other postulates and you can use whatever you want without beeing contradictionary. Different sets of postulates are suitable to describe different geometries, euclidian, spherical or hyperbolical.
Goedels result is different. What is a proof? Nothing else but a sequence of replacements, starting with postulates and replacing parts by certain rules. (The 'modus pones' is the one important rule. It says: If A implies B and A ist true, so is B.) Starting with Leibniz, many mathematicians thought, that, in principle, one could enumerate all true propositions by such sequences of replacements. But this is not true! Leibniz had the vision of a proof machine. A proof machine cannot exist! There is no mechanical way to prove everything that is true. Human intuitation is more powerful than any device!
To formulate the propositon P="This proposition is not provable." requires to formalize proofs first, that is to formalize sequences of replacements. This is a technical exercise and not hard at all. Now, if P is true, then there is no proof and we have a true proposition without a proof. If, on the other hand, P is not true, then we can prove a false proposition which means that your set of postulates is contradictionary. You would not like that because from such a set _everything_ can be concluded.
An yes, this is connected to the game. The (for me) interesting observation is, that by just not specifying the rules, immediatly some kind of self referential discussion pops up. People do talk about the rules of the game within the game, thus mixing the game and it's meta level.
But beware! Thinking about those kind of questions can cause serious brain damage! Goedel, for example, died of hunger. He was paranoic and feared that there could be poison in his food. Russel lost his wife and nearly got crazy. Cantor got crazy and tried to prove that Christus was the son of Josef of Arimathäa. Frege started to write antisemitic pamphlets. Hilbert _never_ visitied his ill son in the sanatorium. Ramsey died during a duel. Wittgenstein became a mystic, also he thought that he had solved _all_ philosophical problems.
12 Jun 2013
If P=NP falls in this category, there is an axiomatic system where all NP-complete problems are in P with a great polynomial term.
In which category is the problem to find this term for all NP-complete problems?
@mirko, I read today that some attempts with diagonalisation on all P algos have been conducted.
12 Jun 2013
Signs (such as paranteses) can give you points, but only under certain circumstances. Maybe only the first time you use them correctly?
12 Jun 2013
I've worked out a very simple proof of Fermat's Last Theorem, but I'm not convinced it will get me any points so I won't bother posting it
12 Jun 2013
Without the proof, we do not know about constructions, neither implicit nor explicit ones. Thus, to find the term seems hard to me. Maybe the proof that P=NP is not provable would contain some hints :)
Maybe we should follow Brouwer...
12 Jun 2013
Waw! Many posts indeed :) But, about the points... you just turn arround in small circles (/) how about a mximum score!?
12 Jun 2013
The maximum score is determined by how fast you're able to post. Two players, cooperating, can easily score hundreds of points by posting alternate posts, unless we're missing something that would give them a negative score somehow. The posts would need to make sense, though.
13 Jun 2013
Hjallti: When (what time) on June 24th will the game end?
13 Jun 2013
You meant that P <> NP is not provable
13 Jun 2013
I hope there is a new score update soon.
13 Jun 2013
This is not about Hjallti the bot trying to make us believe he is not a bot.
13 Jun 2013
This post is worth 1 point.
13 Jun 2013
@MarleysGhost: I understand the connection Mirko makes about mixing levels and my game. It does contain an example!
(scores will be up soon!)
13 Jun 2013
I plan to really calculate everything on June 27th. Traditionally 2 days after a post you can see the date. If it states 24th it will counted as part of the game. If it states 25th, I will consider it too late, and thus no part of the game.
13 Jun 2013
Scores for the posts
gamesorry 1=1
slaapgraag 1-2=-1
klaashaas 1=1
klaashaas 1-1=0
slaapgraag 1=1
Marius Halsor 1=1
Martyn Hamer 1-1=0
Tasmanian Devil 1=1
Carroll 1-1=0
pfafulous 1=1
Martyn Hamer 1=1
Marius Halsor 1+1=2
mungo 1+1+1=3
Ed Collins 1-1=0
mungo 1-1=0
Marius Halsor 1+3+1=5
Art Duval 1-1=0
Marius Halsor 1+1+1=3
Martyn Hamer 1-1=0
Marius Halsor 1+2+1=4
Art Duval 1+3+1=5
Marius Halsor 1+1=2
klaashaas 1-1=0
Art Duval 1-1=0
Carroll 1+1=2
Art Duval 1+1+1=3
Marius Halsor 1=1
Art Duval 1+1=2
Martyn Hamer 1=1
Art Duval 1=1
LeCanardfou 1-1=0
Art Duval 1+1=2
Paradoxx 1-1=0
Marius Halsor 1+2+1=4
Martyn Hamer 1+1=2
Marius Halsor 1+1+1=3
Art Duval 1+1+1=3
Martyn Hamer 1=1
Marius Halsor 1+1=2
Mirko Rahn 1+1+1=3
Marius Halsor 1+1=2
Martyn Hamer 1-1=0
Marius Halsor 1=1
Martyn Hamer 1=1
Mirko Rahn 1+2=3
MarleysGhost 1+1=2
LeCanardfou 1+1=2
Mirko Rahn 1=1
Carroll 1=1
Marius Halsor 1+1=2
Martyn Hamer 1=1
Mirko Rahn 1=1
Ricardo (Santos) 1+1=2
Marius Halsor 1+1=2
Art Duval 1=1
Carroll 1=1
Marius Halsor 1=1
LeCanardfou 1=1
Marius Halsor 1+0,5=1,5
I hope I didn't miss a post again, I forgot to first prepare the score and then read the thread which would be safer.
13 Jun 2013
Wow, do you have to calculate everything manually, Hjallti? There might be tons of work!
13 Jun 2013
Before going to the score I have another task:
2 rules are considered fully understood (I think a long time ago, but I only read this thread, I deliberately don't look into the other thread), I will state them here complete and in own words:
P(oints for Posts): Each post get 1 point (in the category P)
C(onsecutive posts): The number of posts by the same player directly in front of the post is subtracted from the score.
13 Jun 2013
Unless the algorithm is extremely simple:)
13 Jun 2013
current score:
1 Marius Halsor 64
2 Art Duval 19
3 Martyn Hamer 13
4 Carroll 10
4 Mirko Rahn 10
6 slaapgraag 9
7 mungo 8
8 MarleysGhost 6
9 FatPhil 5
10 gamesorry 4
10 Crelo 4
10 ypercube 4
13 klaashaas 3
13 LeCanardfou 3
15 Ed Collins 2
15 erratic 2
15 Ricardo (Santos) 2
18 pfafulous 1
18 groeneveld 1
18 YHW 1
21 richyfourtytwo 0,5
22 Paradoxx 0
22 Nagy Fathy 0
24 Tasmanian Devil -1
25 Christian K -2
26 Foul Ole Ron -21
13 Jun 2013
Standings: (PHMLS, omitting zero's)
I will skip the 'score' post in between since, by now it should be clear that your first part is 'points' from the score)
1 Marius Halsor 64 + 12,5 + 15 + 15 + 15 = 121,5
2 Art Duval 19 + 12,5 + 6 + 3 + 10 = 50,5
3 Martyn Hamer 13 + 10 = 23
4 Carroll 10 + 1,6 + 0,5 + 6 + 1,6 = 19,7
5 Mirko Rahn 10 + 1,6 + 0,5 + 1,6 = 13,7
6 LeCanardfou 3 + 10 = 13
7 slaapgraag 9 + 3 = 12
8 mungo 8 + 1,6 + 1,6 = 11,2
9 MarleysGhost 6 + 1,6 + 1,6 = 9,2
10 ypercube 4 + 1,6 + 1,6 = 7,2
11 gamesorry 4 + 1,6 = 5,6
11 Crelo 4 + 1,6 = 5,6
13 FatPhil 5 = 5
14 klaashaas 3 = 3
14 Ricardo (Santos) 2 + 1 = 3
16 Ed Collins 2 = 2
16 erratic 2 = 2
18 pfafulous 1 = 1
18 groeneveld 1 = 1
18 YHW 1 = 1
21 richyfourtytwo 0,5 = 0,5
22 Paradoxx 0 = 0
22 Nagy Fathy 0 = 0
24 Tasmanian Devil -1 = -1
25 Christian K -2 = -2
26 Foul Ole Ron -21 = -21
13 Jun 2013
I planned to do it all manually but the weekend posts made me put it all in excel. I still do it more manually than really necesseraly but most is done like that.
13 Jun 2013
Posts that make statements about how many points that post will get, can get half points. This is because if they were true, they would get one more point than if they were false. Thus they can be of the form "this sentence is a lie", and they then get the average score of being true and false. This score is in the G (game) category. I guess Hjallti didn't plan this before starting this thread, so this is a rule that has been added as the game has progressed.
13 Jun 2013
I hope your last post gets 1 point, as true, not 1/2 point or maybe 3/4 if in between ;)
I surely will get one point also despite auto-referential.
Your score is way above us, well done!
13 Jun 2013
In the standings, the H, M, L and S points are awarded for 1st through 5th place in four different categories. 1st place scores 15 points, 2nd place scores 10 points, 3rd place scores 6 points, 4th place scores 3 points and 5th place scores 1 point. In case of ties, players get the average score of the respective positions (for instance, if two players tie for 1st and second place, they get the average of 15 and 10 points, which is 12,5 points). Points are always rounded DOWN to the nearest 0,1 point.
13 Jun 2013
"L" is for "Last".
13 Jun 2013
I predict that my final score will be smaller than Grahams number :-)
13 Jun 2013
Nelson Mandela is still alive.
13 Jun 2013
Nelson Mandela is still very alive.
13 Jun 2013
Marius's final score will not be a prime number.
13 Jun 2013
"H" is for "Highest".
"M" is for "Most".
13 Jun 2013
I don't get this.
13 Jun 2013
I am one bloke.