Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

Little Golem Monster Rating

Public forum discussion.

General

#151 · tasuki

21 Nov 2008

Colourful update :)

While the previous version with yellow to red tones was definitely more aesthetically pleasing, I decided to give more colours a try. Yes, it looks awful and hover doesn't work the way it used to.

But it's very easy to just look and see - blue is a beginner, green is intermediate, yellow is advanced and red is an expert.

Please let me know what you think - if this causes several people to poke their eyes out I'll revert it to the previous state :P

#152 · ypercube

21 Nov 2008

Nice. It reminds me of playsite colours: blue, green, yellow, orange, red if I remember well.

You could add purple for rating less than a beginner and white for better than red (expert).

#154 · tasuki

22 Nov 2008

Thanks for the positive feedback :)

I started with full spectrum - purple to red. But the purple was very very prominent and it was almost impossible not to look at it. And as far as the ratings are concerned I don't really care whether someone has 1500 or 1100 - so I don't want to visually discriminate against those who have low rating :P

#155 · Crelo

19 Feb 2009

Just bring it back to attention. I like it.

#157 · Crelo

19 Feb 2009

Well tasuki, only if I could bribe you somehow for several places up...

#158 · Marius Halsor

30 Mar 2009

Yippy! I finally managed to reach 4th place (in the weighted variant, obviously, as that's the only one I bother to look at). That's as high as I'll ever go, I suppose, as the distance between 3rd and 4th place is bigger than between 4th and 18th. I fear I'll go down a few places soon, too.

#159 · bennok

31 Mar 2009

Congrats Marius ! I am also a fan of tasuki's weighted monster rating. I still can't believe sitting as 7th. Couldn't have made it without the introduction of havannah! I expect to fall soon to a more reasonable ranking soon.

#160 · ypercube

22 Apr 2009

tasuki, a recent change in the site's code has caused the EinStein ratings to start dissapearing from your site!

#161 · tasuki

22 Apr 2009

Thanks for letting me know - I corrected it. Too lazy correction though, so it will break next time the name gets changed ^^

#162 · Marius Halsor

4 Jun 2009

Richard has now recalculated all ratings, with everyone starting at 15k in GO, so I think the Monster Rating should now use 15k=1500. Also, GO ratings are set to be one common rating, so there is no need to display all three ratings any more.

Oh, and the Einstein ratings are still broken, unfortunately.

Thanks for maintaining this list, Tasuki!

#163 · tasuki

26 Sep 2009

Hello good people!

I made some changes on LittleGolem Monster Ratings:

First, I deleted go13 and go9. ( I am strongly opposed to the same rating for go19, go13 and go9 - they are different games!... but what can I do?). I also set go ratings to be 15k = 1500 (before it was 14k, so almost no difference).

Second, I deleted most of the user created variations... I left the few I deemed useful.

Third, EinStein name keeps switching there and back... so my regexp was failing (yes, I'm too lazy to create a robust solution). Corrected again, currently updating all (over 20000) players, should be done in an hour or two.

PS: No wonder Marius wanted me to update the ratings - he's 6th now and I fell from 4th place to 12th. Why do you think I waited with the update for 3 months? My ego is thiiiiis big and I had to undergo an extensive therapy to be able to put up with such a failure.

#164 · Marius Halsor

6 Oct 2009

Thanks a lot, Tasuki! I expect that soon there will be only one rating in Hex and Reversi as well, and then the default variant and the weighted variant (which is the only one I keep checking) will be identical. Since I only care about the weighted variant, this update didn't affect me that much, but I think getting Einstein back in might have pushed me up from 6th to 5th (or from 5th to 4th, seeing as the player who is currently 4th is a known cheater).

Perhaps it helps your ego a little knowing that you are making a great site, which I, for one, really appreciate! :-)

PS: At some point, I suppose WYPS should be included too, in some way.

#165 · Marius Halsor

6 Oct 2009

To aviod any misunderstandings: I meant that the player currently rated 4th in the WEIGHTED Monster ratings, formerly known as "Jamaica" and "fairplay", is a cheater. He/she now uses the name "No1_Othello_fourinarow_player". This is fortunately the only exception among the top rated players - in my experience, all the other top Monster-rated players are great, fair, players.

#166 · Hjallti

10 Dec 2009

I am bumping this

I want to get in the top 100 as I feel my skills in some games are raising it should work :-)

#167 · bloke

13 Dec 2009

"No1_Othello_fourinarow_player", a proven cheater, now is on top of the Monster Ratings, which is sad.

Good news, however, that I am above 2500 rating points and within the Top40, for the first time.

Go bloke! :-)

(@Hjallti: I refreshed your rankings and you jumped from No. 127 to 110. You will be within the Top100 before soon.)

#168 · Hjallti

15 Dec 2009

I just saw I am on 112, and I am really getting forward in some games! Thanks and good luck with your rating bloke.

(probably I am already in the top100 of the non cheaters)

#169 · bloke

15 Dec 2009

You may be right: No1_Othello_fourinarow_player, FaiRPlaY, chess_game, Po_W_eR, UsEr_DaTa, and a__________________rad are proven cheaters in the Top100, and there might be others, too.

#170 · Aganju

18 Dec 2009

Why would my ID not show up? Seems like a zillion people get listed, but when I search for my ID its not found (I tried 'Aganju', '21003', and all combinations of upper/lowercase, and even my old nick 'BillBigfoot')

Do you have to be playing for some time? Or what?

#171 · Hjallti

18 Dec 2009

apparently: 395*50=19970 there are less than 20000 players listed and there are 20192 playing.

#173 · tasuki

18 Dec 2009

Actually, the database doesn't update automatically (it would create unnecessary pressure on littlegolem). It updates when someone visits the update link (google helps with this :-)

And when you try to update someone who isn't in the database yet, it creates a new entry. I added Aganju by visiting the url: http://golem.tasuki.org/?action=update&pid=21003

Yes, I know, there could be explanation on the site and an easy, clickable way of doing this... but I thought no one would notice ;P

#174 · Aganju

31 Dec 2009

is there a reason why WYPS is not in there? It would boost my rating....

#175 · tasuki

1 Jan 2010

Yes, the reason is that I'm lazy and didn't notice (yesIknowthatsoundslikeaverysillyexcuse).

I'll try to add WYPS tomorrow, possibly the day after.

If I fail to do that, feel free to throw snowballs at me.

#176 · Aganju

2 Jan 2010

snowballs? what's that? It has 20°C outside (68 F) :-) [yes I love to rub in why I moved to Florida]

tasuki, I'm thankful you did anything at all! I often catch myself doing that, and many others too: it's so easy to complain about what could have been done, but we should always remember that something was done already, and it wasn't done by us.

#177 · tasuki

2 Jan 2010

20°C is nice (thanks for using Celsius first ^^), but as for me, I like snow every now and then :)

I added WYPS to the table - enjoy!

And I might have incidentally deleted a few well-known cheaters from the database ;)

#178 · bloke

3 Jan 2010

Including WYPS is a welcome move. It catapulted me into the Top30. Thanks! :-)

Would you incidentally also take care of EcNaL and Po_W_eR who are also well-known members of the Jamaica Clan? :-)

#179 · FatPhil

4 Jan 2010

Not just those two, I saw about half a dozen of them still on the page. RoRoRo thinks the Jamaica Posse contains the following:

JamaicaPosse members# 17304YeAr2010, No1_Othello_fourinarow_linesof# 17583FaiRPlaY, Jamaica, Never_ending, fAiRpLaY, vayamos# 17305a__________________rad# 17306Ye_L_o# 17396UsEr_DaTa# 19008EcNaL, chess_game# 17578v_a_y_a_m_o_s# 17582va_yam_os# 17592aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa# 19873mk5# 18194mrjekyllxxxdrhyde# 18239Po_W_eR# 17631spelme# 17632jimmmmy# 17633bigmac

#180 · Marius Halsor

5 Jan 2010

Great job, Tasuki! Very nice that you keep the Monster Rating alive. I wonder if Richard soon will make just one rating for Hex and Reversi, like he did with GO - not that it matters much, I just use the "Weighted" variant anyway :-)

#181 · tasuki

5 Jan 2010

YeAr2010 got reincluded in the database, so I decided to implement a simple but effective banning system :)

So far, the winners are: 17304, 17305, 17306, 17396, 17583 and 19008. I'm not sure why FatPhil thinks the others on his list cheat as well, so I left them alone, for the time being.

#182 · FatPhil

5 Jan 2010

Before I make comments I regret (bullcrap, I love flaming the heck out of people) regarding your awareness of the behaviour of the others, almost all of which have had their suspicious behaviour explicitly mentioned on the fora in the last year, quite how much research did you actually do into the games and results of the other players in order to feel confident that you could ignore the above claims?

If you give an answer that's too low, then you'll get flamed for not doing your research.

If you give an answer that's too high, then you'll get flamed for being utterly ineffectual at such research.

So chose your answer wisely. Good luck.

#183 · tasuki

7 Jan 2010

I didn't do much research, the only info I have is "RoRoRo thinks the Jamaica Posse contains the following" and a list of ids. I don't think RoRoRo really cares, but if it goes ahead and explains why it thinks so, I will be very grateful.

Accusing spelme -- who has an amazing rating of 40 points -- of cheating seems very bold. I prefer to err on the side of caution. I'd hate to drop any non-cheaters.

Please be advised that if you flame me, I will throw snowballs at you.

#184 · Marius Halsor

7 Jan 2010

Accusing spelme of "cheating" is actually not that strange, tasuki - despite his low rating. The reason for this is that all the accounts stated above probably belongs to the same person (that's the accustaion, anyway). Some of these accounts are simply sacrificed and drained for rating points so that others can gain rating.

If you look at the games spelme has played, you'll notice a pattern. It's basically only against other nicks on this list. Fairplay is the account who gains the rating points, whereas spelme, jimmmmy and bigmac all lose to Fairplay, and alternate on losing and winning against each other.

Just to be on the safe side: I mean this only as information and an explaination as to why these accounts should be considered cheaters. I don't accuse you of doing a poor job at all. In fact, I'm surprised and very grateful that you take the trouble of removing cheaters at all! :-)

No flames or snowballs from me...

#185 · Hjallti

9 Jan 2010

I got into the top 100 ! Great

#186 · Rex Moore

30 Jan 2010

I've been playing on Little Golem steadily for nearly seven years, and I am just now discovering the Monster Ratings. (I haven't checked the forums steadily, obviously. ;))

Well done, tasuki... bravo! this will have the intended effect of motivating me to play more games.

#188 · idiot

20 Mar 2010

it would be nice to see wyps ascending rating included

#191 · tasuki

21 Mar 2010

Do you mean that you would like to be able to sort any rating in an ascending way?

#192 · idiot

21 Mar 2010

no, there is a game called "ascending wyps" and it has its own individual rating (that does not show up on a player's profile, but it does exist!) For example, click on my current wyps game (ascending wyps) and you will see my ascending rating of 1523 (instead of my normal wyps rating of 1656)

#193 · Aganju

21 Mar 2010

An easy way to see your own rating (probably 1500, if you never played) is to register in the waiting room for a game of ascending WYPS (and delete the entry afterwards - games do start only at midnight). It shows your current rating while you are in there.

You can do this for all other ratings you have, for example for WYPS in other languages, and many other variants of other games.

#194 · ypercube

21 Mar 2010

The problem is that a user (like tasuki) cannot gather the ratings of other players in WYPS ascending and other wyps variations, not easily anyway. These ratings are not shown in a list like the other ratings.

#196 · Greck

22 Mar 2010

the way is via the rating list.

Of course is not as easy as grabbing the data from the player info. But for tasuki maybe it would be profitable to change the whole grabbing system and use the rating lists. This way you get rid of some inactive users...

#197 · ypercube

22 Mar 2010

Oops, I hadn't seen these lists! Then it won't be a problem for tasuki.

#198 · Greck

22 Mar 2010

They are relatively new (for the strange variations). I looked for them (just in case) when klaashaas advertised Ascending WYPS, and bingo! Not sure since when we have them available :-)

by the way, asc-wyps population multiplied by 3 thanks to klaashaas, hehe

#199 · tasuki

22 Mar 2010

Hmmm, if I were to add 'ascending wyps', I'd also have to add the other (not only wyps) obscure variations... which could make a bit of a mess.

Gregorio's idea to gather the ratings from the rating list is good - it would greatly reduce the resources needed for global update of everyone. But I don't do global updates more often than twice a year and I'd have to keep the current method anyway (to update individual users). And I guess I'm a bit lazy, so I'm going to postpone that :)

#200 · Hjallti

22 Mar 2010

tasuki, I don't think so, I don't think any other obscure variation is rated separately. The removal of the doubles seemed to be going for the rule that you have 'each separately calculated rating' and Wyps ascending is the only one you don't have.

Last page