Skip to content
Little GolemMake your next move.

Little Golem Monster Rating

Public forum discussion.

General

#101 · bloke

26 Mar 2008

tasuki, you have every right to be biased, since you have created an excellent site that makes people want to try themselves out in games they otherwise would not play. but.

but to claim is that go, go13 and go19 (or the hexes and reversis) are completely different games is ridiculous.

just look at the monster rankings. in the top 20 there are only a handful of players who would not double or triple their points only because they are good at go (hex or reversi). such all-round players are rare: ray garrison, miuek, t-devil, for example.

but there any many more players who are mediocre besides their top-heavy go performance: xaver gubas and bela nagy are prime examples. beyond the top 20 DZ, gambatte, 12, sorin gherman have a high monster ranking also only due to their go performance. so it is not just nao

#102 · Ruben Berenguel

26 Mar 2008

Bloke, you have played only a little go here (have played more anywhere?). But I think you have played enought, to at least agree with tasuki with 9 and 19go, aren't they completely different games? If you don't, play more games. About the hexes and reversis, I can't tell, I've only played 13x13 hex, and no reversi.

#103 · Marius Halsor

26 Mar 2008

Ruben, what is "different games" is simply a question of definition. In this context, I prefer to consider games with identical rules, but with different board sizes, to be different games. However, I know very well that there are huge differences between playing Hex13 and Hex19. However, The difference between Hex13 and StreetSoccer is far, far bigger. Again, it's a matter of definition.

#104 · Marius Halsor

26 Mar 2008

Correction: "...but with different board sizes, to NOT be different games.". Sorry.

#105 · Ruben Berenguel

26 Mar 2008

Heh Marius you fooled me with your first message. Sure, the difference between let's say, SS and Go9 are bigger than Go9 and Go19, but the skills you use when playing Go19 are not the same you use when you play Go9 (local tactics vs global strategy, things like that).

#106 · tasuki

26 Mar 2008

bloke: Xaver has over 1100 points (that's about a third of his total points) from those games he's "mediocre" at.

I wonder, why is no one complaining that street soccer is included too? It is a completely random game, so the ratings are obviously distorting the monster rating

And once again - as soon as I have the time, I'll make it possible for people to make their own custom monster ratings, based on the criteria they choose. :)

#107 · Marius Halsor

26 Mar 2008

Looking forward to the custom site, tasuki. You're doing a great job! Anyway, I must protest that street soccer is "a completely random game". Sure, chance plays a part - a significant part, even. But there is still skill involved. Stochastic games can be even more complex than other games, as you have to compute probability distributions rather than "just" a game tree. However, due to the random element, rating differences will likely be smaller in random games (SS and Einstein) than entirely deterministic games (at least as long as the deterministic games are sufficiently complex - in Tic Tac Toe, every game would end in a draw, of course).

Ruben: Sure, there are differences between Go9 and Go19 - noone disputes that. But like I said, what constitutes a "different game", is simply a matter of definition. There are many reasons (good ones, in my opinion) why games with identical rules, but different board sizes, should NOT be considered different games, but opinions differ on this matter.

Oh, and sorry for that typo again...

#108 · tasuki

26 Mar 2008

I kind of overlooked the fact that littlegolem removed < and > from my post... It should have been:

I wonder, why is no one complaining that street soccer is included too? It is a completely random game, so the ratings are obviously distorting the monster rating

I'm sorry for the inconvenience and I hope it's clearer now :)

#109 · Bernhard Herwig

26 Mar 2008

It seems so obvious to me: Every strong Go player is strong at all the three sizes of Go, even if the games are quite different. Every Go novice is weak at all three. So of course in Tasukis rating Go has weight 3 and the honorable game of street soccer has weight 1.

#110 · Looser

27 Mar 2008

tasuki: I bet that playing streetsoccer if difference between dices are plus minus 10, I'll defeat you 8 from 10 times. Playing with tigis you may win 1 of 10.

#111 · Greck

27 Mar 2008

looser, tasuki was being ironic ;-) LG deleted is "troll" tags, but later he made them explicit :P

#112 · bloke

28 Mar 2008

if in the real Monster Games go, go13 and go19 are considered versions of the same game, then why not here?

to remain on the ironic side: there is a definitely detectable "go-chauvinism" in tasuki's posts.

the result is that his monster rating calculation remains excessively biased towards go players and favors them -- you cannot deny that.

#113 · ypercube

28 Mar 2008

In the first Monster, the 3 go games were considered different.

#114 · Marius Halsor

28 Mar 2008

...and in the 2nd Monster, they are NOT considered different.

#117 · bloke

28 Mar 2008

in the 2nd MOLG they are NOT considered different for a very obvious reason, i suppose. the reason why i have not signed up for each of the MOLG tournaments is my non-existent go game. but i like the new rules so i will sign up for MOLG3.

#118 · Paulzz

30 Mar 2008

Aren't four in a row, gomoku and connect6 different versions of the same game also?

#121 · bennok

19 May 2008

I have to thank tasuki for the excellent page: I started playing all sorts of new games, and I was very flattered to be on the 0st page (it is really the first but called zero). I was surprised how easy it has been to move up from position 45 to 28. I don't think I'll come much higher than 20 though being a bit over rated in Hex and because of the quality of the opponents up there.

#122 · Greck

20 May 2008

i always thought it's 0th :)

#123 · tasuki

7 Jun 2008

So, I sacrificed yesterday's evening and added the possibility to ( insert fanfare) create your own variations!

I already added two variations (the default rating is a variation for technical reasons, and the new one is "weighted" with go counting only 1/3 and hex 1/2).

New variations, opinions and bugreports are welcome. :-)

#125 · bloke

7 Jun 2008

excellent. the weighted variation is already a great improvement. it should be the default.

a bug: i cannot create a new variation even with a very simple name. the message is that i have not read the rules... what did i do wrong?

#126 · Dom

7 Jun 2008

yes, great work, and i like a lot the two new variations :)

#127 · tasuki

7 Jun 2008

bloke: No, it shouldn't be the default... the default is the one that makes most sense :)

BTW, I created the variations so that people would finally stop arguing which variation is the best ;)

And sorry for the bug - I added a regexp test for name and forgot to test it >.<

I've just corrected it.

#128 · tasuki

7 Jun 2008

Jesus fscking christ...

Whenever a new variation is created, a new indexed column is added to the player database. So I check for people trying to create a variation with a name of already existing column, and of course I forgot to check case-insentitively.

So it happened, that when someone tried creating a variation called "GWG" (there's a possibility to sort by game, btw, no need to create a new variation for that, you ******), it wrote the data over the existing gwg column. So I'm now updating the whole database. Now, when creating a new variation, it checks for every column, so in case some idiot decides to call his variation "last_updated", it will not (hopefully) fuck up my database.

Geez, this made me so angry... (and yes, I know it's my mistake, but I really don't have the time and energy to deal with this so please just stop breaking my stuff, okay? :-)

#129 · Robin

7 Jun 2008

When I inserted my variation it removed an apostrophe.

#130 · tasuki

7 Jun 2008

Robin, it was a bug that even allowed you to enter variation with an apostrophe and space in the name, I have manually corrected it :-)

#131 · Bernhard Herwig

7 Jun 2008

Great work Tasuki! People should not believe in one correct order by strength of the players on Littlegolem. I like "weighted" most, but thats just my personal taste.

#132 · Marius Halsor

7 Jun 2008

I really appreciate your effort, tasuki! This is becoming a great addition to Little Golem.

I have one very small suggestion for an improvement, if you should find the time: In the "weighted" variation, new ratings for the weighted games are calculated and displayed. To me, at least, it would be preferrable to show the actual ratings, but weigh them in the total score.

That is, I'd prefer to do Score=sum(weight(i)*game(i)) rather than Score=sum(wgame(i)), where wgame(i)=weight(i)*game(i).

#133 · Dvd Avins

8 Jun 2008

I created a rating (1000) but there are no names displayed.

#134 · tasuki

8 Jun 2008

I just wonder... why did you call it "1000"? :)

It's working now - I renamed it to "thousand".

I also added another requirement for a variation name - it has to start with a-zA-Z.

#135 · tasuki

8 Jun 2008

Marius, I am not sure I understand what you are saying.

Here is the row (ok, I admit I removed all the undecipherable arrays and replaced them with human-readable variables) that calculates how to display rating for each game (the ratings are saved in the database as I got them, with go being converted the way explained in the about page):

$value = round(($original_value - $variation_cutoff) * ($variation_weight / 100) + 1500);

And I am aware that this might not be intuitive way to display the numbers, if you have any better suggestion, please do share.

#136 · Marius Halsor

8 Jun 2008

Well, all I was trying to say, was that I prefer that you still DISPLAY original_value, and use the weight only in CALCULATING the total score.

#137 · tasuki

8 Jun 2008

Marius: This is funny, your suggestion is pretty obvious (the rating variations don't affect players' ratings in individual games, whatever way they are counted), yet it never occured to me. I did this to be able to verify that the rating calculations are correct (knowing that I wrote it myself, I was actually pretty surprised to find out they are correct ;-)

And I think I'd like the displayed values to somehow relate to the rating, although I'm not sure whether my way (translating the values so that the cutoff value is 1500 again) is good.

For now, if you want to see the "real" ratings, use the default variation :)

#138 · ypercube

17 Jun 2008

I created a games_with_dice_1000 rating, where only EinStein and StreetSoccer ratings count, with 1000 the cut limit.

The results are ok at the Ratings column but not at the streetsoccer and einstein columns. Ratings appear to be 500 higher, although the calcualtions are right.

#139 · tasuki

17 Jun 2008

ypercube: Actually, they are recalculated so that 1500 remains the cutoff value (I think it makes sense to display it this way, but I might have to rethink it, since Marius already had the same complaint as you (just three posts above :-))

#140 · FatPhil

18 Jun 2008

I'm with Marius. It's just plain odd to see your familiar steady-state rating jumping all over the shop depending on what variant you're looking at. However, all in all, it's a great site - thanks!

#141 · Marius Halsor

11 Jul 2008

It seems like the updating does not work. The rating for each game is updated, but the sum is not. I've only checked the weighted variant, though, so I don't know if the others are OK.

#142 · KPT

29 Jul 2008

tasuki

when u are going to refresh this application?

#143 · Marius Halsor

18 Sep 2008

It's sad that the excellent feature with variations no longer work properly. I completely understand that tasuki has other and probably more important things to do than fix this, but it's sad nevertheless.

The bug is rather strange, as the ratings for each individual game is updated, yet the total rating is not. And for the "original" variation, everything works just fine. I keep copying the ratings to Excel and calculate the total ratings there, but it's definitely not a desirable solution.

#144 · bennok

20 Sep 2008

Thanks Marius, I never noticed I was going down in my weighted rating :( Seemingly you've lost even more than I.

#145 · tasuki

21 Sep 2008

First - I'm really sorry to have left you waiting for so long.

The bug was actually fairly trivial - I didn't check the length of the variation name, and in the table containing variations I only saved first 20 characters. Of course, in the player table, there was a column with the original full length name, hence the query failed completely.

It's all working again (I hope, at least), and I promise to be more responsive and responsible next time :)

#146 · Marius Halsor

21 Sep 2008

Thanks a lot for fixing this, tasuki - it's great to see everything working again! :-)

#147 · GWG Only

25 Sep 2008

It seems that "Monster ratings" works only for players 1..16999.

Since my Player_ID is 17284, I cannot see my "Monster rating".

tasuki, could You please fix this problem ?

#148 · tasuki

30 Sep 2008

Hi, I thought 17000 would last longer :)

You can add a player by id like this:

http://golem.tasuki.org/?action=update&pid=17284

Anyway, it's not a hard set limit, it's just the number of rows I decided to initially put into the database (now extended to 20000).

On a completely unrelated note: I decided not to do regular updates of the ratings, as I figured it might be a heavy load on littlegolem. Now I see that googlebot and yahoo slurp have taken care of regular updating while distributing it over longer time periods :-)

#149 · ypercube

1 Nov 2008

tasuki, we need an update on your Monster rating site :)

#150 · tasuki

1 Nov 2008

Oooooook.

Side note: I knew I shouldn't have bothered with the variations - now I had to go through all of them and guess how the creator would have dealt with havannah...

Side note #2: I didn't update the ratings (just few ppl to see whether it works), I'll leave it up to users and googlebot.

Last page