Your games have been analyzed by stockfish? Go forum
9 replies. Last post: 2019-02-05
Reply to this topic Return to forumReturn to forum
You have 0 new messages
You have 0 games on move.
You have 0 invitations to game.
9 replies. Last post: 2019-02-05
Reply to this topic Return to forumWhat is this new feature?
I don't know about a stockfish version for Go, isn't it Leela, it's estimation is quite near on the games where I had Leela to play.
Also for chess, having the estimation of best network of Lc0 would be very nice.
On what hardware have these estimations taken place?
Is this feature for members only?
What does the feature do? Maybe it will be good enough to push me into becoming a member. :)
To try to answer your question, Richard would be the one to answer, but he gave me a few elements:
- for chess he is using Stockfish 9 and it takes about 2 hours,
- for Go he is using Leela Zero (I don't know which network) and it takes about 6 hours !
Here are examples of displays you find as comments of your game,
For 1st move:
Analyze - Stockfish
MOVESWhiteBlackEXCELLENT3830GOOD1417INACCURACY710MISTAKE01BLUNDER00BEST MOVES52.54 %31.03 %Avg. Diff1.011.68
Worst moves: ◎ 48.o2 39.22% -> 28.70%◎ 18.n17 51.21% -> 43.18%◎ 30.c13 41.51% -> 34.18%◉ 119.a1 93.68% -> 87.82%◎ 120.Pass 12.18% -> 6.39%◉ 121.Pass 93.61% -> 87.96%◎ 56.c12 27.06% -> 21.99%◎ 62.p12 23.28% -> 18.34%◎ 118.Pass 10.42% -> 6.32%◉ 37.h17 63.77% -> 59.99%◉ 25.e9 59.08% -> 55.51%
And then on each move something like this:
[EXCELLENT]
Best move: G4 Score: 51.71%
Your move: E2 Score: 48.73%
G4 51.71% G4 H3 H4 J3 J4 K3 C9 C11 E16 D14 C17 B17 D17 H16 E14 E13 F14 D15 D13
C3 50.42% C3 D4 D5 C4 B4 B3 C2 E2 B2 B5 A3 E5 B6 E6 G4 H4
G2 48.70% G2 H2 G4 G1 H3 J3 G2 C4 B4 B3 D4 C3 J2 G3 H4 K2 K3
E2 51.04% E2 G2 C3 D2 C2 C1
Richard also intends to add graphs, like the ones you get on Lichess
How can be a blunder the best move?
https://www.littlegolem.net/jsp/game/game.jsp?gid=2015562&nmove=68
Crelo, did you or brownale ★causethis game to be analyzed?
- or in other words: What made this game, in particular, get analyzed?
I'm sorry I can not yet answer your question (yet?), maybe there is no answer (other than to call it a blunder and “the best move” is an error), but hopefully somebody will have a good answer. :)
I think the quality of the move is off by one move from the move listed.
Also, I think go has a few odd display issues, not related to the actual engine.
Chess seems more stable/developed.
But overall, I like this feature.
A better explanation of my first sentence. In the example given above, “Excellent” refers to the previous move, while “Best move: G4, Your move: E2” refers to the current move.
@Sighris, brownale is a member, I am not, so probably he caused this analysis.
@WIlliam Fraser, indeed, the excelent / blunder seems to refer to the previous move. This way it makes sense.